Limited support for Wirral

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for Wirral Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Annual Council Part Two, Council - Wednesday, 22nd May 2024 6.00 p.m.

May 22, 2024 View on council website Watch video of meeting Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Who was threatened at the town hall?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The meeting focused on several key issues, including the behavior of protesters, the adoption of a revised council constitution, the appointment of committee chairs and vice-chairs, and the allocation of seats on the Liverpool City Region Transport Committee. There was significant debate and disagreement, particularly regarding the fair representation of the Green Party in council roles.

Protester Behavior

  • Discussion: Councillors expressed concern over the behavior of protesters who verbally abused and threatened council members, particularly targeting female members. Councillor Green and Councillor Gilchrist emphasized the need to ensure safety and condemned the aggression.
  • Decision: Legal officers will be given statements to prevent the aggressive protesters from approaching the town hall in the future.

Adoption of Revised Council Constitution

  • Discussion: The council discussed adopting a revised constitution with minor amendments proposed by the Monitoring Officer. Councillor Tony Cox moved the recommendations, and Councillor Gilchrist seconded.
  • Decision: The council adopted the revised constitution for the 2024/2025 municipal year.

Appointment of Committee Chairs and Vice-Chairs

  • Discussion: The Green Party proposed amendments to ensure fair representation in committee chairs and vice-chairs, arguing that the current allocation was undemocratic and excluded Greens from positions of power. Councillor Onwemina, Councillor Jenkins, Councillor Graham, and Councillor Murphy were put forward for various roles.
  • Arguments For: The Greens emphasized fairness, proportionality, and the need for diverse representation, including more women in leadership roles.
  • Arguments Against: Councillors Gilchrist and Stewart argued that the proposals were last-minute and not in line with the council's governance process. They also accused the Greens of seeking power rather than fairness.
  • Decision: The amendments proposed by the Green Party were rejected, and the original motion for committee chairs and vice-chairs was passed with 46 votes in favor, 14 against, and one abstention.

Allocation of Seats on the Liverpool City Region Transport Committee

  • Discussion: The Green Party proposed an amendment to allocate one of the four seats on the Liverpool City Region Transport Committee to a Green councillor, arguing for proportional representation.
  • Arguments For: Councillor Lamb and Councillor Molyneux highlighted the need for fair representation and the importance of having members who use public transport.
  • Arguments Against: Councillor Gilchrist and Councillor Kelly pointed out that the proportionality should be considered across the entire city region, not just within Wirral. They noted that the Greens already had representation from other areas.
  • Decision: The amendment was rejected with 14 votes in favor, 46 against, and one abstention.

Other Appointments

  • Discussion: The council also discussed appointments to other bodies and organizations. The Green Party proposed an amendment for fair representation on these bodies.
  • Decision: The amendment was rejected, and the original motion was passed with 60 votes in favor and one abstention.

Overall, the meeting was marked by significant debate over issues of fairness and representation, with the Green Party's proposals being consistently rejected by the majority of the council.

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorNaomi Graham
Councillor Naomi Graham Green Party • Prenton
Profile image for CouncillorJulie McManus
Councillor Julie McManus Deputy Leader of the Council • Labour • Bidston and St. James
Profile image for CouncillorJudith Grier
Councillor Judith Grier Green Party • Bebington
Profile image for CouncillorBrian Kenny
Councillor Brian Kenny Mayor • Labour • Bidston and St. James
Profile image for CouncillorSimon R Mountney
Councillor Simon R Mountney Conservative • West Kirby and Thurstaston
Profile image for CouncillorAngela Davies
Councillor Angela Davies Deputy Leader of the Labour Group • Labour • Leasowe and Moreton East
Profile image for CouncillorEwan Tomeny
Councillor Ewan Tomeny Green Party • Birkenhead and Tranmere
Profile image for CouncillorHelen Cameron
Councillor Helen Cameron Chair of Audit and Risk Management Committee • Conservative • Clatterbridge
Profile image for CouncillorCraig Walsh - McDonald
Councillor Craig Walsh - McDonald Green Party • Rock Ferry
Profile image for CouncillorMike Sullivan
Councillor Mike Sullivan Vice-Chair of Audit and Risk Management Committee • Labour • Pensby and Thingwall
Profile image for CouncillorGeorge Davies
Councillor George Davies Labour • Claughton
Profile image for CouncillorSue Powell-Wilde
Councillor Sue Powell-Wilde Labour • New Brighton
Profile image for CouncillorAndrew Gardner
Councillor Andrew Gardner Vice-Chair of Economy, Regeneration and Housing Committee • Conservative • Hoylake and Meols
Profile image for CouncillorJames Stewart Laing
Councillor James Stewart Laing Vice-Chair of Regulatory and General Purposes Committee • Labour and Co-operative • Liscard
Profile image for CouncillorMike Redfern
Councillor Mike Redfern Liberal Democrats • Oxton
Profile image for CouncillorAllan Brame
Councillor Allan Brame Liberal Democrats • Oxton
Profile image for CouncillorHarry Gorman
Councillor Harry Gorman Green Party • Prenton
Profile image for CouncillorTony Jones
Councillor Tony Jones Labour • New Brighton
Profile image for CouncillorKieran Murphy
Councillor Kieran Murphy Green Party • Bromborough
Profile image for CouncillorTony Cox
Councillor Tony Cox Conservative • Hoylake and Meols
Profile image for CouncillorJennifer Johnson
Councillor Jennifer Johnson Conservative • West Kirby and Thurstaston
Profile image for CouncillorPaul Stuart
Councillor Paul Stuart Labour • Seacombe
Profile image for CouncillorChris Carubia
Councillor Chris Carubia Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group and Vice-Chair of Children, Young People and Education Committee • Liberal Democrats • Eastham
Profile image for CouncillorJason Walsh - McDonald
Councillor Jason Walsh - McDonald Green Party • Bebington
Profile image for CouncillorGraham Davies
Councillor Graham Davies Independent Conservative Group • Heswall
Profile image for CouncillorGillian Wood
Councillor Gillian Wood Labour and Co-operative • Claughton
Profile image for CouncillorGail Jenkinson
Councillor Gail Jenkinson Co-Leader of the Green Group • Green Party • Greasby, Frankby and Irby
Profile image for CouncillorAndrew Hodson
Councillor Andrew Hodson Independent Conservative Group • Heswall
Profile image for CouncillorStuart Kelly
Councillor Stuart Kelly Chair of Planning Committee • Liberal Democrats • Oxton
Profile image for CouncillorCherry Povall, JP
Councillor Cherry Povall, JP Chair of Regulatory and General Purposes Committee • Conservative • Clatterbridge
Profile image for CouncillorLesley Rennie
Councillor Lesley Rennie Deputy Leader of the Conservative Group • Conservative • Wallasey
Profile image for CouncillorTom Laing
Councillor Tom Laing Labour and Co-operative • Seacombe
Profile image for CouncillorMark Skillicorn
Councillor Mark Skillicorn Chair of Economy, Regeneration and Housing Committee • Labour • Greasby, Frankby and Irby
Profile image for CouncillorMary Jordan
Councillor Mary Jordan Deputy Mayor • Conservative • Clatterbridge
Profile image for CouncillorPaul Martin
Councillor Paul Martin Labour • New Brighton
Profile image for CouncillorJeff Green
Councillor Jeff Green Leader of the Conservative Group and Vice-Chair of Pensions Committee • Conservative • West Kirby and Thurstaston
Profile image for CouncillorTony Murphy
Councillor Tony Murphy Labour • Rock Ferry
Profile image for CouncillorElizabeth Grey
Councillor Elizabeth Grey Chair of Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee • Labour • Bidston and St. James
Profile image for CouncillorVida Wilson
Councillor Vida Wilson Conservative • Moreton West and Saughall Massie
Profile image for CouncillorPhil Gilchrist
Councillor Phil Gilchrist Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group and Vice-Chair of Adult Social Care and Public Health Committee • Liberal Democrats • Eastham
Profile image for CouncillorColin Baldwin
Councillor Colin Baldwin Conservative • Moreton West and Saughall Massie
Profile image for CouncillorIan Lewis
Councillor Ian Lewis Chair of Tourism, Communities, Culture and Leisure Committee • Conservative • Wallasey
Profile image for CouncillorPaul Jobson
Councillor Paul Jobson Labour • Leasowe and Moreton East
Profile image for CouncillorPat Cleary
Councillor Pat Cleary Green Party • Birkenhead and Tranmere
Profile image for CouncillorRichie Pitt
Councillor Richie Pitt Your Party • Pensby and Thingwall
Profile image for CouncillorGrahame McManus
Councillor Grahame McManus Labour • Greasby, Frankby and Irby
Profile image for CouncillorStephen Bennett
Councillor Stephen Bennett Chair of Children, Young People and Education Committee • Labour • Upton
Profile image for CouncillorSteve Foulkes
Councillor Steve Foulkes Vice-Chair of Planning Committee • Labour • Claughton
Profile image for CouncillorAnn Ainsworth
Councillor Ann Ainsworth Labour • Pensby and Thingwall
Profile image for CouncillorKathy Hodson
Councillor Kathy Hodson Leader of the Independent Conservative Group • Independent Conservative Group • Heswall
Profile image for CouncillorJo Bird
Councillor Jo Bird Green Party • Bromborough
Profile image for CouncillorKaitlin Stuart
Councillor Kaitlin Stuart Labour • Seacombe
Profile image for CouncillorMax Booth
Councillor Max Booth Vice-Chair of Environment, Climate Emergency and Transport Committee • Conservative • Hoylake and Meols
Profile image for CouncillorLouise Luxon-Kewley
Councillor Louise Luxon-Kewley Labour • Leasowe and Moreton East
Profile image for CouncillorChristopher Cooke
Councillor Christopher Cooke Green Party • Prenton
Profile image for CouncillorJean Robinson
Councillor Jean Robinson Independent • Upton
Profile image for CouncillorPaula Basnett
Councillor Paula Basnett Leader of the Council • Labour • Rock Ferry
Profile image for CouncillorAmanda Onwuemene
Councillor Amanda Onwuemene Green Party • Birkenhead and Tranmere
Profile image for CouncillorHelen Raymond
Councillor Helen Raymond Liberal Democrats • Eastham
Profile image for CouncillorBrenda Hall
Councillor Brenda Hall Chair of Pensions Committee • Labour • Wallasey
Profile image for CouncillorRuth Molyneux
Councillor Ruth Molyneux Green Party • Bromborough
Profile image for CouncillorGary Bennett
Councillor Gary Bennett Conservative • Moreton West and Saughall Massie
Profile image for CouncillorEd Lamb
Councillor Ed Lamb Co-Leader of the Green Group • Green Party • Bebington

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 22nd-May-2024 18.00 Council

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 22nd-May-2024 18.00 Council

Minutes

Printed minutes 22nd-May-2024 18.00 Council

Additional Documents

Council Supplement 22nd-May-2024 18.00 Council
Enc. 3 for Revisions to the Constitution
Enc. 4 for Revisions to the Constitution
Enc. 5 for Revisions to the Constitution
APPOINTMENTS TO OUTSIDE ORGANISATIONS 202425
APPOINTMENT OF COMMITTEES
Minutes 18032024 Council
Revisions to the Constitution
Enc. 1 for Revisions to the Constitution
Enc. 2 for Revisions to the Constitution
Appointments to Outside Bodies list
Full Council Responsibility of Functions
Appendix 1 Appointment of Committees
4.C COMMMITTEE CHAIRS AND VICE-CHAIRS
4.D Appointments and Nominations to other bodies and organisations
Council Supplement pt.2 22nd-May-2024 18.00 Council
4B - Green amendment
4C - Green Amendment