Limited support for City of Edinburgh

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for City of Edinburgh Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Governance, Risk and Best Value Committee - Tuesday, 4th June, 2024 10.00 am

June 4, 2024 View on council website Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why were councillors worried about "red" audits?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The meeting began with a brief technical issue, but once resolved, the council welcomed new members and discussed various topics, including declarations of interest, outstanding actions, and the internal audit update report.

Internal Audit Update Report

The internal audit update report was a significant focus. Councillor Cowie raised concerns about the number of audits marked in red, amber, and green. Laura Calder, Head of Internal Audit, explained that the audit looks at risk and emphasized the importance of focusing on the right areas, even if it means more issues are found. She noted that the council had an amber annual opinion for the last two years and previously had a red opinion for three to four years.

Policies and Procedures

Councillor Miller and Councillor Jenkinson discussed the importance of policies and procedures. Laura Calder mentioned that while policies provide direction, procedures ensure that work is done correctly. She emphasized the need for documented procedures and quality assurance. Executive directors Amanda Hatton, Pat McGuire, and others provided updates on their efforts to improve policies and procedures within their departments.

Alios (Arms-Length External Organisations)

Councillor Finchendo raised concerns about the internal control arrangements for Alios. Laura Calder explained that while some Alios have internal control work, others do not. The council plans to review the Alio framework to ensure consistency and best practices.

Voids

The discussion on voids highlighted the challenges in managing long-term voids and the need for better data. Sarah Burns and Derek McGowan provided updates on efforts to improve data quality and reduce the number of long-term voids. Councillor Kumar emphasized the importance of addressing long-term voids to avoid increased repair costs.

Trams and ERP Projects

The meeting also covered the internal audit reports on the Trams and ERP projects. Hannah Ross and Laura Calder discussed the agile audit approach used for these projects, which allowed for real-time issue resolution. Councillor Knowles-McVay raised concerns about the lack of reporting on legal issues related to the Trams project, and it was agreed that a briefing note would be provided.

Thrive Mental Health Services

The audit report on Thrive Mental Health Services was discussed, with Councillor Miller raising questions about performance measures and timescales for management actions. Linda Irvine and Pat McGree provided updates on efforts to improve performance reporting and workforce issues.

Safety of Council Heavy Operated Vehicles

The council discussed the safety of council-operated heavy vehicles, particularly around schools. It was agreed that the report would be referred to the Transport and Environment Committee for further consideration.

Library Overdue Fines

The council discussed the proposal to end library overdue fines. An amendment was made to review the budget process to ensure no unfunded pressures are included in future budgets.

Accessibility of Council Information

The council discussed the accessibility of council information and agreed to receive a report on the presentation and accessibility of committee reporting.

The meeting concluded with the agreement to the recommendations and amendments discussed.

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorKate Campbell
Councillor Kate Campbell  Scottish National Party •  Ward 17 - Portobello / Craigmillar
Profile image for CouncillorKatrina Faccenda
Councillor Katrina Faccenda  Scottish Labour •  Ward 13 - Leith
Profile image for CouncillorDan Heap
Councillor Dan Heap  Scottish Green Party •  Ward 7 - Sighthill / Gorgie
Profile image for CouncillorStephen Jenkinson
Councillor Stephen Jenkinson  Scottish Labour •  Ward 2 - Pentland Hills
Profile image for CouncillorSimita Kumar
Councillor Simita Kumar  Scottish National Party •  Ward 15 - Southside / Newington
Profile image for CouncillorAdam Nols-McVey
Councillor Adam Nols-McVey  Scottish National Party •  Ward 13 - Leith
Profile image for CouncillorClaire Miller
Councillor Claire Miller  Scottish Green Party •  Ward 11 - City Centre
Profile image for CouncillorJoanna Mowat
Councillor Joanna Mowat  Scottish Conservatives •  Ward 11 - City Centre
Profile image for CouncillorJack Caldwell
Councillor Jack Caldwell  Scottish Liberal Democrats •  Ward 12 - Leith Walk
Profile image for CouncillorChristopher Cowdy
Councillor Christopher Cowdy  Scottish Conservatives •  Ward 9 - Fountainbridge/ Craiglockhart
Profile image for CouncillorLouise Young
Councillor Louise Young  Scottish Liberal Democrats •  Ward 1 - Almond

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 04th-Jun-2024 10.00 Governance Risk and Best Value Committee

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 04th-Jun-2024 10.00 Governance Risk and Best Value Committee

Additional Documents

8.8 Review of Structural assurance June 24
8.2 Update Report Supplier and Contract Management Internal Audit 2023-24
8.6 Digital Services Quarterly Update
08 - GRBV - 7 May 2024 - Final
8.3 Draft Annual Governance Statement 2023-24
Work programme and appendix 1
8.6 - Addendum - SNP Group
8.10 - Addendum - SNP Group
Motions and Amendments 04th-Jun-2024 10.00 Governance Risk and Best Value Committee
8.1 - Addendum - SNP Group
8.1 - Addendum - Green Group
8.9 - Addendum - SNP Group
7.1 GRBV Business Bulletin - 4 June 2024
8.1 Internal Audit Update Report - June 2024
8.4 Safety of Council Operated Heavy Vehicles
8.5 Award of Contract for Edinburghs Winter Festivals
8.7 Local Government Benchmarking Framework 2022-23 Edinburgh Overview
8.9 Proposals to End Library Overdue Fines - referral from the CC Cttee
8.10 Accessibility of Council Information - referral from PS to GRBV
GRBV Outstanding Actions - 04 June 2024