Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Hillingdon Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Council - Thursday, 11th September, 2025 7.30 pm

September 11, 2025 View on council website

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Will free bin collection charges face committee scrutiny?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

A meeting of Hillingdon Council was scheduled for Thursday, 11 September 2025, covering a range of topics from urgent decisions and cabinet portfolios to questions from both the public and members, as well as several motions. A key item for consideration was the external auditor's report, alongside discussions on financial matters and potential actions the council might take.

External Auditor's Report and Financial Recommendations

The council was expected to consider the recommendations outlined in the External Auditor's report, specifically the Issuance of Recommendations Under Section 24, Schedule 7(2) of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014. This report contained seven formal statutory recommendations, prompting a discussion on whether to accept them and what actions to undertake in response.

The recommendations included:

  • Developing detailed implementation plans for all planned savings in the 2025-26 budget and future financial strategies.
  • Reviewing service delivery models to ensure efficiency and value for money.
  • Balancing the schools' budget to prevent further growth in the Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) deficit[^2]. [^2]: The Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) is a ring-fenced grant for local authorities to fund their maintained schools and academies.
  • Reviewing financial forecasting processes to understand and address the emergence of significant financial pressures.
  • Establishing a clear understanding of the council's current financial position.
  • Addressing issues encountered with the implementation of Oracle EPM[^3] to ensure accurate budgetary information for decision-makers. [^3]: Enterprise Performance Management (EPM) is a management process that helps organisations to plan, budget, forecast and report on business performance.
  • Continuing the development and implementation of the Financial Modernisation Programme and the wider Governance Review Improvement Plan.

The Statutory Recommendations Report noted that the external auditor made seven formal statutory recommendations to the Council under Section 24 Schedule 7(2) of the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014.

The report also emphasised the need for the council to take firm action to address systemic weaknesses in its financial management and governance, both before and after the upcoming council election in May 2026.

Motions

Several motions were scheduled for consideration, covering a range of topics:

  • Councillor Peter Curling's motion focused on the impact of a third runway at Heathrow Airport on the borough and its residents, reaffirming the council's opposition to the expansion.
  • Councillor Sital Punja's motion called for Councillor Eddie Lavery, Cabinet Member for Community and Environment, to reconsider the decision to close the retail operations of the Rural Activities Garden Centre, citing failures in financial analysis, a lack of exploration of alternative providers, and inadequate consultation.
  • Councillor Elizabeth Garelick's motion addressed the decline in the cleanliness of residential streets across the borough, urging the administration to take action to improve frontline services such as refuse collection and street cleansing.
  • Councillor John Riley's motion reaffirmed the council's commitment to promoting civic pride, celebrating its heritage, and supporting the flying of national flags, while also recognising concerns about protests against illegal immigration and asylum seekers.
  • Councillor Stuart Mathers' motion expressed serious concerns about broken promises to residents regarding free weekly bin collections, calling for the implementation and introduction of charges for waste to be referred to the relevant select committee for scrutiny.
  • Councillor Ian Edwards' motion addressed the high number of asylum seekers housed in hotels or dispersed accommodation in Hillingdon, calling on the government to cease evicting former asylum seekers without adequate support and accommodation and to refund the costs borne by Hillingdon's residents.

Questions from Members of the Public

Members of the public had submitted questions on various topics, including:

  • The Rural Activities Garden Centre: Andrea Scrivens and John Scrivens both asked questions relating to the closure of the RAGC, with Andrea Scrivens asking whether the land had been offered for sale, and John Scrivens asking why the council had failed to process the ACV nominations within the statutory time limit.
  • Garden Waste Collection: Lynn Jackson asked why garden waste bags were being collected from homes where no payment had been made.
  • Union Park Estate: Daniel O'Neill, on behalf of the Hillingdon Alliance of Residents' Associations, asked for an update on the building safety issues at Union Park Estate in Cowley.
  • Racial Hatred: Ade Banjoko asked how the council can reassure residents that it takes hate crime seriously.

Questions from Councillors

Councillors had also submitted questions for cabinet members, covering topics such as:

  • Building safety issues at Union Park in Cowley.
  • Progress in preparing for reforms to Children's Social Care.
  • Progress in managing the High Needs budget and the SEND improvement plan.
  • A councillor appearing in a promotional video supporting a third runway at Heathrow.
  • Addressing the Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) deficit.
  • The procurement of Grant Thornton for the Financial Modernisation Programme.
  • Providing an independent report on the council's savings against target for the past 15 years.
  • Providing required information to the independent auditor to establish whether there is misstated information or actual fraud.
  • Reasons for an adverse variance against the outturn for 2024/25.
  • The procurement process for delivering two new Transporter buses.
  • Completing an audit of the council's spaces and buildings.
  • The Home Secretary's approach to illegal immigration.
  • The council's level of borrowing compared to other councils.
  • The rationale behind closing the RAGC to members of the public.
  • The level of Exceptional Financial Support funding needed from central government to avoid a Section 114 Notice[^4]. [^4]: A Section 114 Notice is a formal declaration that a council does not have the resources to meet its financial obligations.

Report of the Head of Democratic Services

The Report of the Head of Democratic Services included updates on urgent decisions that had been implemented. One such decision was an update on the Beck Theatre including interim lease arrangements and payments, finalisation of a long-term lease and capital upgrade works to the Theatre. The report also included a recommendation to note the alteration to Cabinet Portfolios, specifically the transfer of responsibility for Fleet Management from the Finance & Transformation Portfolio to the Planning, Housing and Growth Portfolio.

Attendees

Profile image for %= (person.title + Philip Corthorne MCIPD" class="person-image" >
Councillor Philip Corthorne MCIPD Mayor of Hillingdon • Conservative • Ruislip
Profile image for %= (person.title + Reeta Chamdal" class="person-image" >
Councillor Reeta Chamdal Deputy Mayor, Chair of Pensions Committee • Conservative • Hillingdon West
Profile image for %= (person.title + Naser Abby" class="person-image" >
Councillor Naser Abby Independent • Yiewsley
Profile image for %= (person.title + Shehryar Ahmad-Wallana" class="person-image" >
Councillor Shehryar Ahmad-Wallana Conservative • Colham & Cowley
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kaushik Banerjee" class="person-image" >
Councillor Kaushik Banerjee Conservative • Ickenham & South Harefield
Profile image for %= (person.title + Labina Basit" class="person-image" >
Councillor Labina Basit Chief Whip (Hayes Independent) • Hayes Independent Party Group • Belmore
Profile image for %= (person.title + Adam Bennett" class="person-image" >
Councillor Adam Bennett Conservative • Hillingdon West
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kishan Bhatt" class="person-image" >
Councillor Kishan Bhatt Conservative • Northwood Hills
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jonathan Bianco" class="person-image" >
Councillor Jonathan Bianco Deputy Leader of the Council & Cabinet Member for Corporate Services & Property • Conservative • Northwood Hills
Profile image for %= (person.title + Wayne Bridges" class="person-image" >
Councillor Wayne Bridges Cabinet Member for Community & Environment • Conservative • Hillingdon East
Profile image for %= (person.title + Tony Burles" class="person-image" >
Councillor Tony Burles Labour • Uxbridge
Profile image for %= (person.title + Keith Burrows" class="person-image" >
Councillor Keith Burrows Chair, Registration & Appeals Committee • Conservative • Uxbridge
Profile image for %= (person.title + Roy Chamdal" class="person-image" >
Councillor Roy Chamdal Conservative • Colham & Cowley
Profile image for %= (person.title + Farhad Choubedar" class="person-image" >
Councillor Farhad Choubedar Conservative • Uxbridge
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Curling" class="person-image" >
Councillor Peter Curling Leader of Hayes Independent Group • Hayes Independent Party Group • Hayes Town
Profile image for %= (person.title + Darran Davies" class="person-image" >
Councillor Darran Davies Chair of Licensing Committee • Conservative • Charville
Profile image for %= (person.title + Nick Denys" class="person-image" >
Councillor Nick Denys Chair, Health & Social Care Select Committee • Conservative • Eastcote
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jas Dhot" class="person-image" >
Councillor Jas Dhot Conservative • Yeading
Profile image for %= (person.title + Ian Edwards" class="person-image" >
Councillor Ian Edwards Leader of the Council • Conservative • Eastcote
Profile image for %= (person.title + Scott Farley" class="person-image" >
Councillor Scott Farley Hayes Independent Party Group • West Drayton
Profile image for %= (person.title + Janet Gardner" class="person-image" >
Councillor Janet Gardner Deputy Leader of Hayes Independent Group • Hayes Independent Party Group • Hayes Town
Profile image for %= (person.title + Elizabeth Garelick" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Narinder Garg" class="person-image" >
Councillor Narinder Garg Labour • Belmore
Profile image for %= (person.title + Tony Gill" class="person-image" >
Councillor Tony Gill Deputy Chief Whip (Labour) • Labour • Pinkwell
Profile image for %= (person.title + Martin Goddard" class="person-image" >
Councillor Martin Goddard Conservative • Ickenham & South Harefield
Profile image for %= (person.title + Ekta Gohil" class="person-image" >
Councillor Ekta Gohil Deputy Chief Whip (Conservative) • Conservative • Colham & Cowley
Profile image for %= (person.title + Becky Haggar OBE" class="person-image" >
Councillor Becky Haggar OBE Conservative • Eastcote
Profile image for %= (person.title + Henry Higgins" class="person-image" >
Councillor Henry Higgins Chair, Hillingdon Planning Committee • Conservative • Northwood
Profile image for %= (person.title + Mohammed Shofiul Islam" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Rita Judge" class="person-image" >
Councillor Rita Judge Hayes Independent Party Group • Yeading
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kamal Preet Kaur" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kuldeep Lakhmana" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Eddie Lavery" class="person-image" >
Councillor Eddie Lavery Cabinet Member for Finance & Transformation • Conservative • Ickenham & South Harefield
Profile image for %= (person.title + Richard Lewis" class="person-image" >
Councillor Richard Lewis Conservative • Northwood
Profile image for %= (person.title + Heena Makwana" class="person-image" >
Councillor Heena Makwana Chairman, Children, Families and Education Select Committee • Conservative • South Ruislip
Profile image for %= (person.title + Gursharan Mand" class="person-image" >
Councillor Gursharan Mand Labour • Pinkwell
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kelly Martin" class="person-image" >
Councillor Kelly Martin Conservative • Hillingdon East
Profile image for %= (person.title + Stuart Mathers" class="person-image" >
Councillor Stuart Mathers Leader of the Labour Group • Labour • Wood End
Profile image for %= (person.title + Douglas Mills" class="person-image" >
Councillor Douglas Mills Conservative • Ruislip Manor
Profile image for %= (person.title + Richard Mills" class="person-image" >
Councillor Richard Mills Chief Whip (Conservative) • Conservative • South Ruislip
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Money BSC (Hons) MSc (Res) PhD" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + June Nelson" class="person-image" >
Councillor June Nelson Chief Whip (Labour) • Labour • Heathrow Villages
Profile image for %= (person.title + Barry Nelson-West" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Susan O'Brien" class="person-image" >
Councillor Susan O'Brien Cabinet Member for Children, Families & Education • Conservative • Ruislip Manor
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jane Palmer" class="person-image" >
Councillor Jane Palmer Cabinet Member for Health & Social Care • Conservative • Harefield Village
Profile image for %= (person.title + Sital Punja" class="person-image" >
Councillor Sital Punja Deputy Leader of the Labour Group • Labour • Yiewsley
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Riley" class="person-image" >
Councillor John Riley Chair, Corporate Resources & Infrastructure Select Committee • Conservative • Ruislip
Profile image for %= (person.title + Raju Sansarpuri" class="person-image" >
Councillor Raju Sansarpuri Labour • Hayes Town
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jagjit Singh" class="person-image" >
Councillor Jagjit Singh Labour • Belmore
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Smallwood OBE" class="person-image" >
Councillor Peter Smallwood OBE Chair, Residents' Services Select Committee • Conservative • Ruislip
Profile image for %= (person.title + Colleen Sullivan" class="person-image" >
Councillor Colleen Sullivan Conservative • Hillingdon East
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jan Sweeting" class="person-image" >
Councillor Jan Sweeting Labour • West Drayton
Profile image for %= (person.title + Steve Tuckwell" class="person-image" >
Councillor Steve Tuckwell Cabinet Member for Planning, Housing & Growth • Conservative • South Ruislip

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 11th-Sep-2025 19.30 Council.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 11th-Sep-2025 19.30 Council.pdf

Additional Documents

250911 - Order of Business.pdf
250911 - 07 - External Audit S24 Report.pdf
250911 - 06 - Report of Head of Dem Services.pdf
250911 - 07 - Statutory Recommendations Report.pdf
250911 - 09 - Motions.pdf
250911 - 05 - Questions from public.pdf
250911 - 08 - Questions from Members.pdf
Minutes of Previous Meeting.pdf