Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Cornwall Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Individual Decision Days - Wednesday, 29th October, 2025 10.00 am

October 29, 2025 View on council website

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Which farms lack "future service value"?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Here is a summary of the business scheduled to be discussed at the Individual Decision Days meeting of Cornwall Council. The meeting was scheduled to cover individual decisions from the Leader of the Council & Group Leader - Liberal Democrat Group, Councillor Leigh Frost, and the Portfolio Holder for Economic Regeneration and Investment, Councillor Tim Dwelly. The topics scheduled for discussion included ensuring that defence-led investment in Devonport creates opportunities for the people and communities of Cornwall, and the rationalisation and release of several farmhouses and estates. The meeting was also scheduled to address questions from the public.

Council Farm Estate

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to discussing the rationalisation and release of various farmhouses and estates owned by the council. The report pack included individual reports for each property, detailing recommendations for declaring them surplus to requirements and authorising their disposal on the open market. The reports referenced the Council Farms Estate 20 Year Strategy & 10 Year Business Plan, adopted in December 2019, which anticipates a reduction in the number of Fully Equipped Holdings (FEH) while maintaining the overall acreage of the estate. The properties under consideration were:

  • Lower Trebrown Farmhouse, Saltash: The report recommended declaring the property surplus and disposing of it on the open market. The wider holding was assessed, with the Asset Management Plan (AMP) and Head of Property decisions attached as exempt Appendix 2. The plan included reletting three bare land opportunities and applying for England Woodland Creation Offer funding for tree planting.
  • Resparveth (west) Farmhouse, Grampound Road: Similar to Lower Trebrown, the report recommended declaring the farmhouse surplus and disposing of it on the open market. The Resparveth estate consists of two main farm holdings and a parcel of land with buildings used for livestock and equestrian purposes. The Asset Management Plan suggested rationalising the two holdings into one, releasing one of the farmhouses and amalgamating the remaining land with the existing tenant of Resparveth (east) farm.
  • Treburthes Farmhouse, Ruan Highlanes: The report recommended declaring both farmhouses, farm buildings, and approximately 23 acres of land surplus and disposing of them on the open market. The Treburthes Farm estate consists of two farms, Treburthes 1&2 and No.3 Treburthes, providing a total of just under 194 acres. The Asset Management Plan also suggested creating two bare land opportunities and applying for England Woodland Creation Offer funding for tree planting.
  • Treneath Farmhouse, Liskeard: The report recommended declaring the farmhouse, farm buildings, and approximately 23 acres of land surplus and disposing of them on the open market. Treneath Farm is currently just under 70 acres. The Asset Management Plan suggested amalgamating the land to the west of the property with South Hendra Farm and extending tree planting on land to the east.
  • Meudon Farmhouse, Falmouth: The report recommended declaring the farmhouse surplus and disposing of it on the open market. Meudon Farm is currently just under 115 acres. The Asset Management Plan suggested reletting the wider holding on a bare land basis with farm buildings for 11 years, with a provision for the council to regain possession of part of the farm for community benefit.
  • Barwick and Furda Farms Estate, Tregony: The report sought approval to declare parts of the Barwick and Furda Farms estate surplus and dispose of them on the open market. The estate extends to approximately 112 hectares and is currently comprised of four lettable units. The Asset Management Plan proposed reverting Furda Farm from a dairy farm to a mixed livestock farm, releasing a pair of semi-detached houses, and amalgamating land to the adjoining Higher Barwick farm.
  • Coosewartha Farm, St Agnes: The report sought approval to declare part of Coosewartha Farm surplus and dispose of it on the open market. Coosewartha Farm currently extends to approximately 59.2 hectares. The Asset Management Plan suggested releasing the farmhouse and land, reletting bare land opportunities, and renewing the lease agreement with the parish council for allotment land.

The report pack stated that the divisional ward member for each property had been consulted. Each report contained a section on the Cornwall Development and Decision Wheel, stating that the proposed disposal had been assessed as not requiring a Decision Wheel because it was unlikely that there would be any material change of use.

The reports noted that the 2019 Farms Strategy remains the principle behind decision making on the Council Farms Estate, but these decisions are taken against the wider financial pressures faced by the Council. Each report contained the following statement:

The Council cannot hold properties which offer no future service value or limited commercial value and therefore disposal is the required outcome.

Defence Led Investment in Devonport

Councillor Leigh Frost was scheduled to discuss ensuring that the defence led investment in Devonport creates opportunities for the people and communities of Cornwall. A Devonport National Defence Growth Area Memorandum of Understanding was included in the report pack.

Questions From The Public

Time was set aside on the agenda for questions from the public to both Councillor Leigh Frost and Councillor Tim Dwelly. The supplementary pack included the questions that had been submitted to Councillor Tim Dwelly. These included questions about the number of affordable homes delivered through the ERDF and ESF programmes, and the number of homes that had been empty for more than six months. The supplementary pack included the questions that had been submitted to Councillor Leigh Frost. These included questions about the Department for Culture Media and Sport DCMS Grant to Cornwall Council to Deliver the Youth Transf.

Attendees

Profile image for Leigh Frost
Leigh Frost  Leader of the Council & Group Leader - Liberal Democrat Group •  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for Tim Dwelly
Tim Dwelly  Portfolio Holder for Economic Regeneration and Investment •  Independent
Profile image for Hilary Frank
Hilary Frank  Portfolio Holder for Children, Families and Schools •  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for Peter La Broy
Peter La Broy  Portfolio Holder for Housing •  Independent
Profile image for Sarah Preece
Sarah Preece  Portfolio Holder for Tourism, Localism and Planning •  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for Kate Ewert
Kate Ewert  Group Leader - Labour and Co-operative Group •  Labour & Cooperative Party
Profile image for Debra Clegg
Debra Clegg  Labour & Cooperative Party
Profile image for Dick Cole
Dick Cole  Group Leader - Mebyon Kernow Group •  Mebyon Kernow
Profile image for Laurie Magowan
Laurie Magowan  Deputy Group Leader - Labour and Co-operative Group •  Labour & Cooperative Party
Profile image for Rob Parsonage
Rob Parsonage  Reform UK
Profile image for Martyn Alvey
Martyn Alvey  Deputy Group Leader - Conservative Group •  Conservative
Profile image for Alan Rowe
Alan Rowe  Labour & Cooperative Party

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 29th-Oct-2025 10.00 Individual Decision Days.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 29th-Oct-2025 10.00 Individual Decision Days.pdf

Additional Documents

Rationalisation and Release of Lower Trebrown Farmhouse Saltash - Report.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Lower Trebrown Farmhouse Saltash - Appendix 1.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Resparveth west Farmhouse - Report.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Resparveth west Farmhouse - Appendix 1.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Treburthes Farmhouse Ruan Highlanes - Report.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Treburthes Farmhouse Ruan Highlanes - Appendix 1.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Treneath Farmhouse Liskeard - Appendix 1.pdf
Rationalisation and Release of Treneath Farmhouse Liskeard - Report.pdf
Release of Meudon Farmhouse Falmouth - Report.pdf
Release of Meudon Farmhouse Falmouth - Appendix 1.pdf
Release of Meudon Farmhouse Falmouth - Appendix 2 - EXEMPT.pdf
Future management and asset release - Barwick and Furda Farms Estate Tregony - Report.pdf
Future management and asset release - Barwick and Furda Farms Estate Tregony - Appendix 1.pdf
Future management and asset release - Coosewartha Farm St Agnes - Report.pdf
Future management and asset release - Coosewartha Farm St Agnes - Appendix 1.pdf
Supplementary Pack - Public Questions 29th-Oct-2025 10.00 Individual Decision Days.pdf
Questions from the Public to the Portfolio Holder for Economic Regeneration and Investment.pdf
Questions from the Public to the Leader of the Council.pdf
Devonport National Defence Growth Area Memorandum of Understanding.pdf
Supplementary Pack - Individual Decisions for the Leader 29th-Oct-2025 10.00 Individual Decision D.pdf
Department for Culture Media and Sport DCMS Grant to Cornwall Council to Deliver the Youth Transf.pdf
Department for Culture Media and Sport DCMS Grant to Cornwall Council to Deliver the Youth Transf.pdf
Department for Culture Media and Sport DCMS Grant to Cornwall Council to Deliver the Youth Transf.pdf
Department for Culture Media and Sport DCMS Grant to Cornwall Council to Deliver the Youth Transf.pdf
Department for Culture Media and Sport DCMS Grant to Cornwall Council to Deliver the Youth Transf.pdf