Limited support for North East Derbyshire

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for North East Derbyshire Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Council - Monday, 22nd September, 2025 2.00 pm

September 22, 2025 View on council website  Watch video of meeting

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Will 19 recycling operatives be enough?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Here is a summary of the scheduled meeting of North East Derbyshire Council. The council is expected to discuss motions relating to Rosh Hashanah, local government reorganisation and fishing at Wingerworth Lido, as well as answering a question about the number of homes planned for the district. Also on the agenda is a report regarding the implementation of Simpler Recycling, and a report regarding the Derby and Derbyshire Strategic Leadership Board.

Simpler Recycling

The council is scheduled to discuss a report from Lee Hickin, Managing Director and Head of Paid Service, regarding the implementation of the Simpler Recycling scheme.

The report recommends that the council:

  • Note the detail and background contained within the Cabinet paper at Appendix 1.
  • Note the decisions made by Cabinet on 11th September 2025 relating to the above.
  • Approve the recruitment and establishment of 19 FTE operatives for implementation of the food waste service operation.

The report notes that the Environment Act 2021 determines new waste collection methodology throughout the nation, and the timeframe for implementation. It says that the establishment changes needed for implementation are the responsibility of the council under the legislation.

The report also refers to a Cabinet report on Simpler Recycling from 11 September 2025, which notes the statutory changes to waste collection including Simpler Recycling, Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) and Deposit Return Scheme (DRS).1

The Cabinet report also details the financial implications of delivering the requirements of Simpler Recycling:

BUDGETS 2024/25 2025/26 2026/2027 2027/28
ACTUAL BUDGET - FOOD WASTE - FOOD WASTE - FOOD WASTE - FOOD WASTE -
MTFP MTFP BUDGET ADD COSTS MTFP BUDGET ADD COSTS
203,679 0 838,391 0 863,316
Existing spend for garden & Food Existing spend for Dry recycling 741,468 898,140 852,106 944,968 875,790 984,141 149,525 0 897,105 1,006,831 153,164 0
Existing processing costs 333,362 350,000 350,000 0 350,000 0
Recycling credit income -615,765 -612,000 -612,000 0 -612,000 0
total cost 1,357,205 1,738,752 1,597,931 987,916 1,641,936 1,016,480
EPR Income/grant Funding (387,901) 0 (1,021,901) 0 (1,021,901)
Total estimated costs 1,357,205 1,350,851 1,597,931 -33,985 1,641,936 -5,421
Change to status quo -184,222 -33,985 -5,421

The Cabinet report also notes that the Head of Paid Service is responsible for and has delegated authority to determine all staffing matters relating to structure including additions, reductions, post title changes and other changes to the establishment amongst other things.

Local Government Reorganisation

Councillor Ross Shipman, Leader of North East Derbyshire Independents Group, has submitted a motion noting a BBC report from August 2025, which revealed that the government has not undertaken any financial impact assessment of its proposals for local government reorganisation2.

The motion resolves to:

  • Oppose the Government's current proposals for reorganisation until a full, independent financial impact assessment has been commissioned and published.
  • Call on the Secretary of State to delay any further decisions or implementation until such an assessment is completed and subject to proper public and parliamentary scrutiny.
  • Affirm this Council's willingness to work constructively with partners on any evidence-based reforms which genuinely improve efficiency and protect local democracy.
  • Write to the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, and to copy local MPs, the County Councils Network and the District Councils Network, to convey this Council's position.

Rosh Hashanah

Councillor Stuart Fawcett has submitted a motion noting that Rosh Hashanah3 begins at sundown on the day of the meeting.

The motion notes that although only around 100 residents in North East Derbyshire identify as Jewish, they are a valued part of the community, and that antisemitism is rising sharply. It refers to the Community Security Trust (CST), which recorded 4,103 antisemitic incidents in 2023, the highest annual total on record. The motion also refers to the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, adopted by this council, which states that antisemitism can include anti-Zionist rhetoric that denies Jewish people the right to self-determination.

The motion resolves to:

  • Publicly reaffirm, through this motion, warm wishes for a sweet New Year to Jewish residents and communities in Derbyshire.
  • Reaffirm adoption of the IHRA definition of antisemitism and endorse its use as a framework for recognising and addressing prejudice.
  • Request the Community Safety Partnership (CSP) to embed antisemitism awareness in policing and safety strategies, with regular monitoring and review by the Communities Scrutiny Committee.
  • Reject antisemitism in all its forms and work with the Jewish community and CST to prevent and respond to incidents.

Wingerworth Lido

Councillor David Hancock has submitted a motion regarding the recent decision to prohibit fishing at Wingerworth Lido.

The motion notes that the Lido is a long-standing community asset, valued for recreation, wellbeing and heritage, and that for generations, fishing has been an important activity enjoyed by residents of all ages. It says that many residents feel that the reasoning behind the decision to stop fishing has not been adequately explained or tested in public.

The motion resolves to:

  • Review the decision to prohibit fishing at Wingerworth Lido, ensuring that the process is transparent, evidence-based, and includes consideration of environmental, maintenance and safety concerns.
  • Undertake a public consultation with residents and local stakeholders on the future use and management of the Lido, including the question of fishing, so that community voices are central to shaping its future.
  • Report back to Council with recommendations that balance environmental stewardship, community wellbeing, and the wishes of residents, ensuring that the outcome is transparent and clearly communicated.

Local Plan

Councillor Alex Dale, Leader of the Conservative Group, has proposed a question to Councillor Stephen Pickering, Portfolio Holder for Environment and Place, regarding the Local Plan.

Councillor Alex Dale asks whether Councillor Stephen Pickering will give serious consideration to the 'Option 2' approach set out in the Local Plan Issues and Options consultation, which would plan for fewer homes (330dpa) than the Government's standard method requires. He cites significant concern expressed by residents that building nearly 600 homes per year is totally unsustainable for a largely rural district such as theirs and that a lower figure, more closely aligned with local needs and infrastructure capacity, should instead be pursued.

Derby and Derbyshire Strategic Leadership Board

The council is scheduled to discuss a report of the Managing Director and Head of Paid Service regarding the Derby and Derbyshire Strategic Leadership Board. This item is scheduled to be discussed after the exclusion of the public, according to Paragraph 3, Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Local Government Act 1972.


  1. Simpler Recycling is a government initiative to standardise recycling collections across England. Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) shifts the financial responsibility for packaging waste from taxpayers to the producers who place packaging on the market. A Deposit Return Scheme (DRS) is a government initiative aimed at reducing litter and increasing recycling of single-use drinks containers. 

  2. Local government reorganisation refers to proposed changes to the structure of local government in the area. 

  3. Rosh Hashanah is the Jewish New Year, a time of reflection, renewal, and hope. 

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorLee Hartshorne
Councillor Lee Hartshorne Chair of the Council & Chair of Planning Committee • Labour • Grassmoor
Profile image for CouncillorGraham Baxter MBE
Councillor Graham Baxter MBE Vice Chair of the Council • Labour • Dronfield North
Profile image for Councillor Frank Adlington-Stringer
Councillor Frank Adlington-Stringer Green Party • Wingerworth
Profile image for CouncillorPat Antcliff
Councillor Pat Antcliff Conservative • Wingerworth
Profile image for CouncillorNeil Baker
Councillor Neil Baker Conservative • Wingerworth
Profile image for CouncillorNigel Barker
Councillor Nigel Barker Leader of the Council & Portfolio Holder for Strategic Leadership & Finance • Labour • North Wingfield Central
Profile image for CouncillorJayne Barry
Councillor Jayne Barry Portfolio Holder for Growth & Assets • Labour • North Wingfield Central
Profile image for Councillor Richard Beech
Councillor Richard Beech Labour • Eckington North
Profile image for CouncillorJoseph Birkin
Councillor Joseph Birkin Portfolio Holder for Council Services • Labour • Sutton
Profile image for CouncillorDavid Cheetham
Councillor David Cheetham Labour • Dronfield South
Profile image for Councillor Kathy Clegg
Councillor Kathy Clegg Labour • Eckington South and Renishaw
Profile image for CouncillorStephen Clough
Councillor Stephen Clough Conservative • Killamarsh West
Profile image for CouncillorAndrew Cooper
Councillor Andrew Cooper Independent Group • Pilsley and Morton
Profile image for CouncillorSuzy Cornwell
Councillor Suzy Cornwell Chair of Business Scrutiny Committee • Labour • Holmewood and Heath
Profile image for CouncillorCharlotte Cupit
Councillor Charlotte Cupit Conservative • Shirland
Profile image for Councillor Alex Dale
Councillor Alex Dale Leader of the Conservative Group • Conservative • Unstone
Profile image for CouncillorLilian Deighton
Councillor Lilian Deighton Conservative • Gosforth Valley
Profile image for CouncillorMichael Durrant
Councillor Michael Durrant Chair of Communities Scrutiny Committee • Labour • Grassmoor
Profile image for CouncillorPeter Elliott
Councillor Peter Elliott Conservative • Brampton and Walton
Profile image for CouncillorMichelle Emmens
Councillor Michelle Emmens Conservative • Gosforth Valley
Profile image for CouncillorStuart Fawcett
Councillor Stuart Fawcett Labour • Eckington South and Renishaw
Profile image for CouncillorClive Fletcher
Councillor Clive Fletcher Labour • Killamarsh West
Profile image for CouncillorMark Foster
Councillor Mark Foster Conservative • Coal Aston
Profile image for CouncillorChristine Gare
Councillor Christine Gare Labour • Eckington North
Profile image for CouncillorTony Lacey
Councillor Tony Lacey Labour • Killamarsh East
Profile image for CouncillorHeather Liggett
Councillor Heather Liggett North East Derbyshire Independents • Shirland
Profile image for CouncillorNicki Morley
Councillor Nicki Morley Labour • Clay Cross North
Profile image for CouncillorFran Petersen
Councillor Fran Petersen Labour • Clay Cross South
Profile image for CouncillorStephen Pickering
Councillor Stephen Pickering Portfolio Holder for Environment & Place • Labour • Eckington South and Renishaw
Profile image for CouncillorKevin Gillott
Councillor Kevin Gillott Portfolio Holder for Local Government Reorganisation • Labour • Pilsley and Morton
Profile image for CouncillorDavid Hancock
Councillor David Hancock North East Derbyshire Independents • Tupton
Profile image for CouncillorDaniel Higgon
Councillor Daniel Higgon Labour • Pilsley and Morton
Profile image for CouncillorPam Jones
Councillor Pam Jones Conservative • Barlow and Holmesfield
Profile image for CouncillorWilliam Jones
Councillor William Jones Conservative • Dronfield South
Profile image for CouncillorPat Kerry
Councillor Pat Kerry Deputy Leader of The Council & Portfolio Holder for Strategic Leadership & Finance • Labour • Sutton
Profile image for CouncillorCarol Lacey
Councillor Carol Lacey Chair of the Licensing Committees • Labour • Killamarsh West
Profile image for CouncillorStephen Reed
Councillor Stephen Reed Reform UK • Killamarsh East
Profile image for CouncillorCarolyn Renwick
Councillor Carolyn Renwick Conservative • Ridgeway and Marsh Lane
Profile image for CouncillorMichael Roe
Councillor Michael Roe North East Derbyshire Independents • Shirland
Profile image for CouncillorKathy Rouse
Councillor Kathy Rouse Portfolio Holder for Health & Leisure • Labour • Clay Cross North
Profile image for CouncillorRoss Shipman
Councillor Ross Shipman Leader of North East Derbyshire Independents Group • North East Derbyshire Independents • Tupton
Profile image for CouncillorDerrick Skinner
Councillor Derrick Skinner Labour • Clay Cross South
Profile image for Councillor Caroline Smith
Councillor Caroline Smith Chair of Environment Scrutiny Committee • Labour • Dronfield South
Profile image for CouncillorChristine Smith
Councillor Christine Smith Chair of Audit Committee • Labour • Dronfield North
Profile image for CouncillorMick Smith
Councillor Mick Smith Chair of Services Scrutiny Committee • Labour • North Wingfield Central
Profile image for CouncillorRichard Spooner
Councillor Richard Spooner Conservative • Coal Aston
Councillor Jessica Stokes North East Derbyshire Independents • Clay Cross North
Profile image for CouncillorLee Stone
Councillor Lee Stone Labour • Holmewood and Heath
Profile image for CouncillorKevin Tait
Councillor Kevin Tait Conservative • Dronfield Woodhouse
Profile image for CouncillorMartin E Thacker MBE JP
Councillor Martin E Thacker MBE JP Conservative • Brampton and Walton
Profile image for CouncillorRichard Welton
Councillor Richard Welton Conservative • Gosforth Valley
Profile image for CouncillorHelen Wetherall
Councillor Helen Wetherall Leader of the Independent Group • Independent Group • Ashover
Profile image for CouncillorPam Windley
Councillor Pam Windley North East Derbyshire Independents • Tupton

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 22nd-Sep-2025 14.00 Council.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 22nd-Sep-2025 14.00 Council.pdf

Additional Documents

Minutes 14072025 Council.pdf
Cabinet Report Simpler Recycling 9-9-25 v 6 003 002.pdf
Council Report Simpler Recyling.pdf