Housing Standards Enforcement Policy
November 10, 2026 Cabinet Member for Housing and Homelessness (Cabinet member) Key decision Awaiting outcome View on council websiteFull council record
Purpose
To seek approval of the Housing Standards Enforcement Policy, taking account of new duties, which provides the framework of when and how the Council will take action regarding rented property legislation within the Borough.
Decision
That adoption of the draft Housing Standards Enforcement Policy 2026 at Appendix 1 to the report to be approved.
Reasons for the decision
The Renters’ Rights Act introduces a significantly expanded civil penalty framework and places new duties on the Council to enforce a broader range of landlord obligations. This includes new compliance requirements, enhanced penalties for repeat or serious non-compliance, and clearer expectations that enforcement activity is fair, consistent and proportionate. To meet these requirements, the Council must ensure its relevant policies are fully aligned with the new legislative framework.
The Councils existing Housing Standards Enforcement Policy was developed prior to the introduction of the Renters’ Rights Act and do not reflect the suite of new offences or amendments to penalty or evidential thresholds.
Without updated policies, there is a risk of inconsistent enforcement, legal challenge to decisions and reduced ability to demonstrate compliance with statutory guidance and best practice. Updating these policies is essential to ensure the Council can meet its statutory obligations.
The Council’s current Housing Standards Policy was developed within a regulatory framework where local authorities retained broad discretion to resolve non-compliance through informal or advisory action, reflecting the principles of the Regulators’ Code. That approach assumed enforcement was generally discretionary and that informal resolution would often be appropriate as a first response. This framework underpins much of the Council’s existing regulatory practice.
The Renters’ Rights Act represents a fundamental shift from that position. Section 107 places a statutory duty on local housing authorities to enforce landlord legislation, altering the balance between informal action and formal enforcement. Where breaches of the defined ‘landlord legislation’ are identified, the Council must now actively consider enforcement action to meet this duty, rather than defaulting to advice or informal resolution in the first instance. As a result, the Regulators Code can no longer be relied upon to justify informal action as the starting point for compliance under the Renters’ Rights Act.
Historically, enforcement of private rented sector legislation has varied significantly between local housing authorities. Differences in local policy frameworks, penalty setting mechanisms and approaches to escalation have led to what is termed as a ‘postcode lottery’ for landlords, where similar breaches may result in markedly different enforcement outcomes depending on the authority involved. This inconsistency risks undermining confidence in the regulatory system, creates uncertainty for landlords operating across multiple areas and increases the likelihood of challenge to enforcement decisions. This also results in discrepancies to the level of tenant protections.
In response to these concerns, the voluntary group, Association of Chief Environmental Health Officers (ACEHO) has developed a suite of national model policies, including an Enforcement Policy, with a further policy on Civil Penalty Debt Recovery (currently in development). These policies are intended to promote greater consistency, transparency and robustness in local authority enforcement approaches, while allowing for appropriate local discretion where appropriate. Aligning the Council’s policies with this nationally recognised framework supports a consistent and defensible approach to enforcement, reduces the risk of unfavourable outcomes to legal challenge and strengthens the Council’s ability to meet its statutory duties.
The implementation of the Renters’ Rights Act requires a coordinated and timely update to the Council’s Enforcement Policy and associated legislation to ensure compliance with the new statutory duties and offences. Failure to update these frameworks risks inconsistency in enforcement decisions and activities, increasing exposure to challenge, as well as an inability to demonstrate that the Council is meeting its statutory duties to enforce landlord legislation. Approval is therefore sought to adopt the proposed policy aligning the Council’s enforcement approach with the new legislative framework.
It is proposed that the new policy take effect from 1 December 2026.
Legal and compliance risk: There is a risk that failure to adopt updated enforcement policy aligned with the Renters’ Rights Act could result in the Council being unable to demonstrate compliance with our statutory duty to enforce landlord legislation under Renters’ Rights Act 2025 section 107. This may increase the likelihood of successful challenge to enforcement decisions, particularly where informal action is relied upon without clear justification, or where penalty-setting lacks a transparent and consistent framework.
Mitigation: Adoption of the proposed policy, with clear decision-making criteria will provide a defensible and legally robust basis for enforcement action.
Consistency and reputation risk: Inconsistent application of enforcement powers may contribute to perceptions of a “postcode lottery” for landlords, undermining confidence in the Council’s regulatory approach and damaging its reputation as a fair and proportionate regulator. This risk is heightened where landlords operate across multiple local authority areas.
Mitigation: Adoption of the policy will support consistency and transparency in enforcement outcomes.
Operational and implementation risk: The introduction of new policies alongside a transitional period where legacy cases are concluded under existing policies, may create complexity for officers and decision makers, with a risk of procedural error or misapplication of policy.
Mitigation: Clear internal guidance, officer briefings, and defined transitional arrangements based on the date of offence and management oversight will support correct application of the appropriate policy framework during the transition period.
Challenge and appeals risk: The expanded use of civil penalties under the Renters’ Rights Act may lead to an increase in representations, appeals, and non-payment of penalties, particularly during the early stages of implementation.
Mitigation: A clear and consistent enforcement approach, and alignment with emerging best practice, including the development of a dedicated civil penalty debt recovery framework, will support effective recovery and reduce the risk of 16 protracted disputes. The policy frameworks have been developed with regard to decisions made at court, the First-tier and Upper-tier Tribunals.
Capacity and resource risk: The enhanced enforcement expectations under the Renters’ Rights Act may place additional pressure on officer capacity, particularly during the initial implementation phase.
Mitigation: Clear policies will streamline decision-making, reduce rework, and support more efficient enforcement activity. A newly introduced case triage matrix will be adapted ready for Renters Rights Act duties will enable correct prioritisation of cases and ongoing monitoring will allow emerging capacity issues to be identified and addressed.
The matter was considered and supported by the Housing Policy Advisory Committee on 4 November 2026.
Alternative options considered
Option 2: To retain existing policies with minor amendments only and making limited amendments to the current Enforcement Policy with reference the Renters’ Rights Act, without adopting a revised framework.
Option 3: To not adopt the draft policy.
Option 2 was not selected as it may cause confusion to officers, landlords and tenants and increase legal challenge. Options 2 and 3 may also have the following implications:
• Policies will not adequately reflect the statutory duty to enforce under Renters’ Rights Act 2025 section 107
• Ongoing risk of inconsistency across the Borough
• Reduced clarity for officers, landlords and tenants
• Higher likelihood of legal challenge and policy failure under scrutiny
• Reputational risk for ineffectively implementing relevant legislation.
Supporting Documents
Details
| Reference | 0 |
| Outcome | For Determination |
| Decision date | 10 Nov 2026 |
| Effective from | 18 Nov 2026 |
| Plan published | 4 Nov 2026 |
| Lead officer | Philip Jennings |
| Subject to call-in | Yes |