Decision to Direct Award OCC's Non-Domestic Water Supply and Wastewater Contract

October 1, 2026 Deputy Chief Executive – Place (Officer) Key decision Approved View on council website
Full council record

Purpose

Direct award of the Council’s non-domestic water supply and wastewater contract to Anglian Water Business (National) Limited t/a Wave Utilities on a 2+1+1 contract term.

Decision

The Deputy Chief Executive of Place decides as follows:

To direct award the Council’s non-domestic water supply and wastewater contract to Anglian Water Business (National) Limited t/a Wave Utilities on a 2+1+1 contract term.  Indicative two-year cost: £454,534.59, this is subject to wholesale charges changes and consumption.

Reasons for the decision

1.    The contract has been procured through a framework via a direct call off process, meaning no specific competition has been held by the Council to select the chosen supplier. For this specific contract the direct award approach represents the most robust and value for money procurement route available to the Council at this time because of the following reasons:

a.    Wave Utilities is the Council’s current supplier and to award a new contract to them avoids the above costs and risks entirely. The supplier already hold validated consumption data, understands the Council’s estate, and provides established billing accuracy. Wave Utilities was independently ranked as the highest?scoring supplier for service quality when appointed to the framework. This combined with the cost savings identified above provides assurance that the appointment will secure best value service for the Council;

b.    The non?domestic water market is highly constrained with wholesale water prices set regionally and regulated nationally, meaning suppliers do not compete meaningfully on water tariffs. Most of the price organisations pay per unit is set by the wholesaler and only approximately 7% of the total cost goes to the retailer. The Council contracts with a retailer for its water provision and under the framework agreement, the retailer’s prices are fixed for the duration of the contract and have already been market?tested and benchmarked through a competitive procurement exercise in order to be appointed to the framework;

c.     Under the framework agreement there are two suppliers on Lot 1 eligible for direct award. Which supplier is selected depends on the criteria chosen. Within this exercise it Laser Energy advised that any marginal difference of costs between the two suppliers would not amount to any substantial cost savings because of the retail costs are a very small percentage of the total water bill. For example, even if a retailer offers ‘half’ the price of another this likely constitutes a 1-2% price difference;

d.    Any marginal difference in retailer fees would be far outweighed by the additional costs and risks associated with a supplier change. Switching supplier would require estate?wide closing meter reads, which cannot be undertaken with existing staff resources and would require short?term additional capacity at an estimated £25,000 revenue cost. Incomplete or delayed meter reads would result in estimated billing, increasing the risk of overcharging and generating avoidable disputes and additional officer time;

e.    The Council has been impressed with the level of service Wave Utilities has delivered throughout the current contract period. A direct call off procurement to appoint also avoids a time and resource intensive competition which will likely deliver no service benefit and no or negligible price benefit given the environment of the water market.

Alternative options considered

1.    Mini-competition via the Framework – The Council could have asked Laser Energy to run a mini-competition between four framework suppliers based on the Council’s requirements for service, social value and price. However, this option was not recommended because.

a.    Duplicates existing work already completed through Laser’s framework procurement.

b.    Requires additional Council resources to manage and evaluate the process.

c.     Creates timing risks, with potential exposure to deemed rates if a new contract could not be awarded before the current one expires.

d.    Costs more, with Laser charging 3% for a mini competition compared to 1.5% for a Direct Award.

e.    Offers limited added value, as Laser has already undertaken a full competitive procurement and Wave achieved the highest service score.

f.      Could cause operational disruption if a supplier change required meter readings across numerous sites.

g.    Introduces unnecessary risk during Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) through potential billing and service continuity issues.

h.    Full standalone procurement outside the framework -  this option was rejected because it would be more time consuming and costly than using an established framework, it would also duplicate procurement work already completed by Laser Energy, and be difficult to undertake ahead of LGR.

2.    Direct award to the alternative framework supplier on Lot 1 – this option was rejected because Wave Utilities achieved the highest score in service on Laser’s framework procurement, and changing suppler would create additional resource pressure and increase billing risks

3.    Running a full standalone procurement – this option was rejected for the following reasons: excessive time and administrative costs compared with using an established framework and because LASER’s framework agreement provides a market-tested and competitive tender prices, meaning a standalone procurement would duplicate work already being undertaken at a sector level.

Supporting Documents

Delegated Decisions Form - Water Contract 25_08 LEGAL REVIEWED 1.pdf
260603 Water Supply Wastewater Contract - Cabinet Report V3 1 1.pdf
Appendix 2 - Risk Register 2.pdf
Appendix 3 - Equality-Impact-Assessment- Water Supply Wastewater Contract Cabinet 1.pdf

Details

OutcomeRecommendations Approved
Decision date1 Oct 2026
Effective from6 Oct 2026
Plan published22 Oct 2026
Lead officerAlice Jones
Subject to call-inYes