To approve the entering into of a temporary licence to occupy between Oxford City Council and Creation Theatre Limited for the occupation and use of Elsfield Hall pending its redevelopment for affordable housing.
November 18, 2026 Director of Housing (Officer) Approved View on council websiteFull council record
Purpose
To enter a temporary licence to occupy between Oxford City Council and Creation Theatre Limited for the occupation and use of Elsfield Hall pending its redevelopment for affordable housing.
Decision
The Director of Housing decides as follows:
- To approve the grant of a temporary licence to occupy Elsfield Hall to Creation Theatre Limited, subject to any minor amendments required and to be agreed as needed to finalise the agreement.
- To approve the inclusion of provisions enabling the Council to recover possession as required to facilitate surveys, investigations, demolition works or redevelopment activities associated with the future affordable housing scheme.
Reasons for the decision
1. The proposal provides a strong financial, operational and community benefit case for the Council. As the owner of a vacant building, the Council is currently liable for business rates of £111,720 per annum. Under the proposed arrangement, Creation Theatre Limited (“the licensee”) would become the rateable occupier of the building and, as a registered charity, would be eligible for mandatory charitable rates relief of 80%. The Council would meet the remaining 20% liability, reducing its annual business rates exposure to £22,344 per annum and generating an annual saving of £89,376.
- The proposal also improves the Council's insurance position. As a vacant building earmarked for future demolition and redevelopment, the Council has been unable to secure building insurance cover. Bringing the property back into active occupation will enable insurance cover to be obtained, reducing exposure to risks associated with fire, vandalism, trespass and other incidents.
- The arrangement will reduce risks associated with vacancy, including deterioration of the building, unauthorised access, anti-social behaviour and vandalism, whilst ensuring the asset remains in beneficial use during the pre-development phase.
- The licence will not affect the Council's ability to deliver the future affordable housing development, and will not affect the delivery programme, given the extensive work required before redevelopment can commence. Furthermore, the licence will contain an unconditional rolling break clause enabling the Director of Housing to recover possession on 14 days’ notice if required by the Council or appointed contractors to undertake surveys, investigations, demolition, site preparation or redevelopment works.
- The licensee will accept the building in its current condition and will be responsible for all operational requirements associated with its use. This includes maintaining £10 million Public Liability Insurance appropriate to temporary public events and immersive theatre activities, undertaking and implementing fire risk assessments, securing all necessary Temporary Event Notices and complying with all relevant health and safety requirements. The licence will also contain indemnity provisions protecting the Council against third-party claims, property damage and personal injury liabilities arising from the licensee's occupation and activities.
- The proposal is also expected to reduce expenditure associated with managing a vacant building, including security, public liability, monitoring and vandalism-related costs. Whilst these savings cannot be quantified precisely at this stage, they represent an additional financial benefit of occupation.
- The proposal therefore secures significant financial savings, improves the Council's risk position, supports a local charitable organisation and ensures beneficial interim use of the property whilst preserving complete flexibility to bring forward the affordable housing redevelopment.
Alternative options considered
Leave the building vacant. This option is not recommended. The HRA would remain liable for approximately £111,720 per annum in business rates and would continue to face the risks associated with owning a vacant building. The property would generate no community benefit and would remain vulnerable to vandalism, deterioration, trespass and anti-social behaviour. The Council would also continue to face difficulties in obtaining insurance cover.
Supporting Documents
Details
| Outcome | Recommendations Approved |
| Decision date | 18 Nov 2026 |