Decision

That Torbay Council will not proceed with establishing a Local Authority Multi-Academy Trust at this time. The Council will instead adopt a strategic facilitation role, clearly communicate its position to maintained schools and support them to identify suitable, high-quality trust partners. Trust-matching and support activity will emphasise sustainable governance, school improvement capacity, financial resilience, inclusion, Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND), community collaboration and commitment to Torbay’s place-based priorities.

Reasons for the decision

The number of schools potentially available to join an LA MAT is insufficient to provide the scale, infrastructure, specialist capacity and economies needed for a strong and sustainable trust. Creating a new Trust would require significant governance, leadership, finance, estates, Human Resources (HR), risk and compliance infrastructure, while generating substantial financial and operational risk. It would also create potential conflicts between the Council’s statutory responsibilities and any role as trust sponsor or governance participant. Supporting schools to join established high-quality trusts is therefore the more proportionate, deliverable and sustainable option, while enabling the Council to retain its role as convenor, commissioner, champion for children and strategic partner.

Alternative options considered

Two options were considered. Option 1, establishing an LA MAT, offered potential benefits through local stewardship, community focus and alignment with place-based priorities, but was rejected because the available scale was too small and the governance, financial, operational, capacity and conflict-of-interest risks were high. Option 2, supporting maintained schools to join existing high-quality trusts, was accepted because it provides access to established trust infrastructure, governance, school improvement and financial systems, avoids the cost and capacity required to create a new trust, and is more deliverable and sustainable. This was considered at the Director’s Overview Meeting (DOM) on 28 July 2026.