Limited support for Sheffield

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for Sheffield Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Did construction materials address noise concerns?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The council meeting focused on several planning applications and community concerns, with significant discussion on a contentious development proposal for Brooklyn's Avenue. Decisions were made on tree preservation, footpath diversions, and residential development applications.

  1. Tree Preservation Order 474:

    • Decision: Confirmed the order to protect two mature beech trees.
    • Arguments: Objectors claimed the order was unnecessary due to existing good arboricultural management and no change in property ownership. Supporters emphasized the trees' community value and ecological benefits.
    • Implications: Ensures long-term preservation of the trees, enhancing local biodiversity and landscape character.
  2. Footpath Diversions (SHE/162 and another at Sky Edge):

    • Decision: Approved the legal diversion of public footpaths to better align with current usage and safety.
    • Arguments: Proponents argued the changes would reflect actual foot traffic patterns and improve safety. There were no significant objections.
    • Implications: The decision will streamline path layouts, potentially reducing maintenance costs and improving public access and enjoyment.
  3. Residential Development at Brooklyn's Avenue:

    • Decision: Approved the construction of four detached dwellings.
    • Arguments: Supporters cited the housing shortage and minimal environmental impact with proposed mitigation. Opponents, including local councillor Mike Chaplin, argued it would lead to overdevelopment, increased traffic, and loss of privacy.
    • Implications: Approval might set a precedent for similar developments, impacting future council decisions on urban density and design standards.

Interesting Event: The meeting acknowledged Councillor Peter Price's last planning meeting, marking an end to his service with applause from colleagues, highlighting the community and continuity within the council. The council meeting primarily focused on planning and development issues, including the approval of new housing developments and the confirmation of a Tree Preservation Order (TPO). The discussions were detailed, with input from councillors, residents, and experts.

  1. Diversion of Public Footpaths: The committee approved the diversion of public footpaths SHE-116 and SHE-301. The decision was based on the paths being overgrown and underused. The new routes will link existing paths and improve accessibility. There were no significant objections, and the decision is expected to enhance local connectivity and recreational opportunities.

  2. Tree Preservation Order (TPO) 474: The council confirmed TPO 474 to protect two mature beech trees. Despite objections from the property owners who felt the TPO was unnecessary due to their ongoing maintenance of the trees, the council decided to confirm the order, citing the trees' significant contribution to local amenity and biodiversity. This decision underscores the council's commitment to preserving green spaces and biodiversity within urban settings.

  3. Residential Development at 45A Brooklyn's Avenue: After extensive debate, the council approved the construction of four new detached dwellings. Previous applications for development on this site were rejected, but changes in the proposal and a recent planning inspector's decision influenced the council's approval. Concerns were raised about increased traffic, potential overlooking, and ecological impact. However, the approval was granted with conditions to manage noise through specific construction materials and to ensure biodiversity net gain, reflecting a compromise between development needs and community concerns.

The meeting also highlighted the council's procedural focus, with detailed discussions on each agenda item and careful consideration of community feedback and expert reports. The decisions made reflect a balance between development and conservation priorities.

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorGlynis Chapman
Councillor Glynis Chapman Liberal Democrats • Mosborough
Profile image for CouncillorAlan Woodcock
Councillor Alan Woodcock Joint Chair of the Planning and Highways Committee • Liberal Democrats • East Ecclesfield
Profile image for CouncillorMike Chaplin
Councillor Mike Chaplin Joint Chair of the Planning and Highways Committee • Labour • Southey
Profile image for CouncillorTony Downing
Councillor Tony Downing Labour • Mosborough
Profile image for CouncillorBarbara Masters
Councillor Barbara Masters Liberal Democrats • Ecclesall
Profile image for CouncillorLaura Moynahan
Councillor Laura Moynahan Deputy Chair of the Communities, Parks and Leisure Policy Committee • Labour and Co-operative • Manor Castle
Profile image for CouncillorIbby Ullah
Councillor Ibby Ullah Deputy Chair of Economic Development, Skills and Culture Policy Committee • Labour and Co-operative • Nether Edge and Sharrow
Profile image for CouncillorCliff Woodcraft
Councillor Cliff Woodcraft Liberal Democrats • Fulwood
Profile image for CouncillorGarry Weatherall
Councillor Garry Weatherall Sheffield Community Councillors Group • Shiregreen and Brightside
Profile image for CouncillorRichard Williams
Councillor Richard Williams Chair of the Charity Trustee Sub-Committee • Liberal Democrats • Stannington

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

20240430 - Agenda
Agenda frontsheet Tuesday 30-Apr-2024 14.00 Planning and Highways Committee
AgendaAttachmentApril23

Reports Pack

Public reports pack Tuesday 30-Apr-2024 14.00 Planning and Highways Committee

Minutes

Printed minutes Tuesday 30-Apr-2024 14.00 Planning and Highways Committee

Additional Documents

Covering Report
Planning Appeals Report 30 April 2024
Signed Report SHE217 SHE301
Minutes of Previous Meeting
Appendix A - Shirecliffe
Signed Report SHE217 SHE301
Appendix A - Skye Edge
TPO 474 committee Report FINAL
Signed Report SHE162
Item 7 - Proposed diversion of public footpath SHE162 at Shirecliffe Sheffield 5 Tuesday 30-Apr-2
Supplementary Report
Planning Applications - Supplementary Information Tuesday 30-Apr-2024 14.00 Planning and Highways