Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Carmarthenshire Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Planning Committee - Monday, 17th November, 2025 12.00 pm

November 17, 2025 at 12:00 pm Planning Committee View on council website Watch video of meeting

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Will councillors request a site visit before deciding?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Open Council Network is an independent organisation. We report on Carmarthenshire and are not the council. About us

The Planning Committee of Carmarthenshire Council met on Monday 17 November 2025 to determine a single planning application. The committee granted planning permission for a One Planet Development at Land North West of Cwmcastell Fawr, Carmarthen, SA33 6EG, subject to several conditions.

Determination of Planning Applications

The committee granted planning permission for a One Planet Development1 at Land North West of Cwmcastell Fawr, Carmarthen, SA33 6EG. This development will comprise a single-storey dwelling, ancillary buildings, and horticultural and coppice areas.

The decision was made subject to three additional conditions:

  • The development will be limited to a total of ten public events per year, including workshops and volunteer days.
  • Any events held must be confined to 'Field 1' as marked on the site plan.
  • A scheme must be produced and implemented to thicken the hedgerow between 'Field 1' and 'Field 2' to mitigate future noise disturbances.

The application was recommended for approval by the Head of Place and Sustainability, with the report detailing how the proposal met the criteria for a One Planet Development as set out in national planning policy, including Technical Advice Note 6 (TAN 6) and its associated practice guidance. The applicants provided a comprehensive management plan and ecological footprint analysis, demonstrating how the development would support two adults with their food, income, energy, and waste assimilation needs from the site within five years. The plan outlined extensive land-based activities, including vegetable gardens, livestock, orchards, and coppice areas, alongside proposals for renewable energy generation from solar panels and sustainable water management.

During the meeting, two residents raised objections to the application, citing concerns about previous noise issues, insufficient vehicle access, and a lack of community engagement. The local member, Councillor Jean Lewis, who is also a member of the Planning Committee, addressed the committee, acknowledging the residents' concerns and requesting a condition to mitigate noise. The applicant and the Senior Development and Enforcement Manager, Hugh Towns, responded to the issues raised.

The report highlighted that the proposed development would result in an overall benefit for biodiversity, with careful consideration given to existing features on the site. The applicants' management plan detailed plans for conserving and enhancing hedgerows, planting trees, and creating ponds. The ecological footprint analysis indicated that the applicants' predicted footprint would fall to 1.53 global hectares per capita after five years, exceeding the target set out in TAN 6.

The committee also noted that the development would be subject to a Section 106 agreement to tie the dwelling to the land and ensure it remains the sole residence for the occupants. Conditions were also imposed regarding highway safety, including visibility improvements at the access, and the management of surface water run-off. The temporary accommodation on site was also required to be removed within three months of the dwelling's first occupation.


  1. A One Planet Development (OPD) is a type of sustainable development in Wales that aims to allow people to live in the countryside while having a minimal environmental impact. It requires residents to meet their basic needs for food, income, energy, and waste assimilation from the land they occupy. ↩

Attendees

Profile image for Cllr. Tyssul Evans
Cllr. Tyssul Evans Plaid Cymru Llangyndeyrn
Profile image for Cllr. Sue Allen
Cllr. Sue Allen Independent Whitland
Profile image for Cllr. Mansel Charles
Cllr. Mansel Charles Plaid Cymru Llanegwad
Profile image for Peter Cooper
Peter Cooper Welsh Labour Saron
Profile image for Cllr. Terry Davies
Cllr. Terry Davies Plaid Cymru Tyisha
Profile image for Cllr. Ken Howell
Cllr. Ken Howell Plaid Cymru Cenarth and Llangeler
Profile image for Cllr. John James
Cllr. John James Unaffiliated - Independent Burry Port
Profile image for Cllr. Jean Lewis
Cllr. Jean Lewis Plaid Cymru Trelech
Profile image for Cllr. Dai Nicholas
Cllr. Dai Nicholas Independent Llandybie
Profile image for Cllr. Dorian Phillips
Cllr. Dorian Phillips Plaid Cymru Llanboidy
Profile image for Cllr. Edward Skinner
Cllr. Edward Skinner Welsh Labour Hengoed
Profile image for Cllr. Russell Sparks
Cllr. Russell Sparks Plaid Cymru Carmarthen Town West
Profile image for Cllr. Gareth Thomas
Cllr. Gareth Thomas Plaid Cymru Hendy
Profile image for Cllr. Michael Thomas 
Cllr. Michael Thomas  Welsh Labour Pembrey
Profile image for Cllr. Elwyn Williams
Cllr. Elwyn Williams Plaid Cymru Llangunnor
Profile image for Cllr. Stephen Williams
Cllr. Stephen Williams Unaffiliated - Independent Elli
Lle Gwag

Topics

Head of Place and Sustainability One Planet Development at Land North West of Cwmcastell Fawr, Carmarthen, SA33 6EG Senior Development and Enforcement Manager Carmarthenshire Council One Planet Development Technical Advice Note 6 (TAN 6)

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 17th-Nov-2025 12.00 Planning Committee.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 17th-Nov-2025 12.00 Planning Committee.pdf

Minutes

Printed minutes 17th-Nov-2025 12.00 Planning Committee.pdf

Additional Documents

Addendum Plans 17th-Nov-2025 12.00 Planning Committee.pdf
Report.pdf
Addendum Plans.pdf