Limited support for Flintshire

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for Flintshire Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Special Meeting, Education, Youth & Culture Overview & Scrutiny Committee - Friday, 10th May, 2024 10.00 am

May 10, 2024 View on council website Watch video of meeting Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required) Watch video of meeting Watch video of meeting

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why exclude the public, despite Councillor Parkhurst's arguments?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The meeting focused on whether to exclude the press and public from discussions due to the sensitive nature of the topics being addressed. The committee decided to move to a private session after a debate on the matter.

The meeting began with Teresa Colbrey, the chair, introducing herself and the officers present, including Gary Schotten, Sharon Thomas, and Stephen Goodrum. Apologies were noted from Councillor Christine Jones and Mrs. Wendy White, with Councillor Richard Jones and Councillor Malbukly substituting for Councillor David Richardson and Councillor Gladys Healy, respectively.

The main topic of discussion was whether to exclude the press and public from the meeting. Councillor Andy Parkhurst argued against the exclusion, citing Section 12A of the Local Government Act. He listed several reasons why the meeting should be public, including the public interest in understanding the case, the issue generating public debate, and the need for transparency and accountability in decisions involving public money. He emphasized that the services discussed affect nearly every resident of the county and involve substantial financial risks for the council.

In response, the chief executive explained that the monitoring officer had considered all points and concluded that the meeting should be private due to the commercial negotiations involved, which are sensitive and confidential. The committee then voted in favor of moving to a private session.

The chair reiterated the importance of openness and transparency but stressed that the confidentiality of commercially sensitive matters must be maintained until the appropriate time.

Attendees

Profile image for CllrRichard Jones
Cllr Richard Jones  Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Transformation Growth and Place •  Independent •  Buckley: Bistre East
Profile image for CyngAdele Davies-Cooke
Cyng Adele Davies-Cooke  Conservative •  Gwernaffield and Gwernymynydd
Profile image for CyngPaul Johnson
Cyng Paul Johnson  Deputy Leader of the Council and Cabinet Member for Finance and Social Value •  Labour •  Holywell West
Profile image for CllrJason Shallcross
Cllr Jason Shallcross  Leader of the Independent Group •  Independent •  Saltney Ferry
Profile image for CllrDavid Richardson
Cllr David Richardson  Non Aligned •  Connah's Quay: Golftyn
Profile image for CllrDennis Hutchinson
Cllr Dennis Hutchinson  Independent •  Buckley: Pentrobin
Profile image for CllrMike Allport
Cllr Mike Allport  Independent •  Higher Kinnerton
Profile image for CllrAndy Hughes
Cllr Andy Hughes  Independent •  Connah's Quay: Golftyn
Profile image for CyngDave Hughes
Cyng Dave Hughes  Leader of the Council / Leader of the Labour Group •  Labour •  Llanfynydd
Profile image for CllrHelen Brown
Cllr Helen Brown  Cabinet Member for Housing and Communities •  Independent •  Hawarden: Aston
Profile image for CllrRyan McKeown
Cllr Ryan McKeown  Labour •  Broughton South
Profile image for CllrTina Claydon
Cllr Tina Claydon  Labour •  Mold West
Profile image for CllrMarion Bateman
Cllr Marion Bateman  Chair of Community & Housing Overview & Scrutiny Committee •  True Independents •  Northop
Profile image for CllrCarolyn Preece
Cllr Carolyn Preece  Flintshire People's Voice •  Buckley: Bistre West
Profile image for CyngMared Eastwood
Cyng Mared Eastwood  Cabinet Member for Education, Welsh Language, Culture and Leisure •  Eagle •  Argoed and New Brighton
Profile image for CllrAndrew Parkhurst
Cllr Andrew Parkhurst  Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group •  Liberal Democrats •  Cilcain
Profile image for CllrGlyn Banks
Cllr Glyn Banks  Cabinet Member for Waste and Transportation •  Labour •  Llanasa and Trelawnyd
Profile image for CllrMel Buckley
Cllr Mel Buckley  Chair of the Council •  Labour •  Flint: Oakenholt
Profile image for CllrCarol Ellis
Cllr Carol Ellis  Leader of the True Independents Group •  True Independents •  Buckley: Mountain
Profile image for CllrGina Maddison
Cllr Gina Maddison  Vice-Chair of Education, Youth and Culture Overview & Scrutiny Committee •  Labour •  Llanasa and Trelawnyd
Profile image for CllrDan Rose
Cllr Dan Rose  Flintshire People's Voice •  Buckley: Bistre West
Profile image for CllrGillian Brockley
Cllr Gillian Brockley  Flintshire People's Voice •  Hawarden: Aston
Profile image for CllrDave Mackie
Cllr Dave Mackie  True Independents •  Hawarden: Ewloe
Profile image for CyngAllan Marshall
Cyng Allan Marshall  Independent •  Treuddyn
Profile image for CllrDebbie Owen
Cllr Debbie Owen  Vice-Chair of the Council •  Independent •  Connah's Quay Central
Profile image for CllrAlasdair Ibbotson
Cllr Alasdair Ibbotson  Flintshire People's Voice •  Penyffordd
Profile image for CllrSam Swash
Cllr Sam Swash  Leader of the Flintshire People's Voice Group / Chair of Social and Health Care Overview and Scrutiny Committee •  Flintshire People's Voice •  Hawarden: Mancot
Profile image for CllrKevin Rush
Cllr Kevin Rush  Vice-Chair of Community and Housing Overview and Scrutiny Committee •  Labour •  Bagillt
Profile image for CllrIan Roberts
Cllr Ian Roberts  Labour •  Flint: Castle
Profile image for CllrRoz Mansell
Cllr Roz Mansell  True Independents •  Connah's Quay: Wepre
Profile image for CyngBill Crease
Cyng Bill Crease  Deputy Leader of the Independent Group / Chair of Corporate Resources Overview & Scrutiny Committee •  Independent •  Connah's Quay South
Profile image for CllrLinda Thew
Cllr Linda Thew  True Independents •  Northop
Profile image for CyngGladys Healey
Cyng Gladys Healey  Vice-Chair of Planning Committee •  Labour •  Hope
Profile image for CyngPaul Cunningham
Cyng Paul Cunningham  Labour •  Flint: Coleshill and Trelawny
Profile image for CllrTeresa Carberry
Cllr Teresa Carberry  Chair of Education, Youth and Culture Overview and Scrutiny Committee •  Labour •  Mold: Broncoed
Profile image for CllrDavid Coggins Cogan
Cllr David Coggins Cogan  Deputy Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group •  Liberal Democrats •  Gwernaffield and Gwernymynydd
Profile image for CllrArnold Woolley Dip.IM, MCMI
Cllr Arnold Woolley Dip.IM, MCMI  Leader of the Eagle Group •  Eagle •  Buckley: Bistre East
Profile image for CllrRobert Davies
Cllr Robert Davies  Chair of Licensing Committee •  Independent •  Bagillt
Profile image for CyngRichard Lloyd
Cyng Richard Lloyd  Chair of Planning Committee •  Labour •  Saltney Ferry
Profile image for CllrChrissy Gee
Cllr Chrissy Gee  Independent •  Broughton South
Profile image for CllrRoy Wakelam
Cllr Roy Wakelam  Independent •  Penyffordd

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 10th-May-2024 10.00 Education Youth Culture Overview Scrutiny Committee

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 10th-May-2024 10.00 Education Youth Culture Overview Scrutiny Committee

Additional Documents

Decisions 10th-May-2024 10.00 Education Youth Culture Overview Scrutiny Committee