Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Doncaster Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee - Thursday, 12th November, 2026 10.00 am

November 12, 2026 at 10:00 am Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee View on council website  Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“What will the committee scrutinize on November 12th?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Open Council Network is an independent organisation. We report on Doncaster and are not the council. About us

The Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee of Doncaster Council met on Thursday, 12th November 2026, to discuss the Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) for 2027/28 to 2029/30. The committee noted the projected budget gaps for these years and provided comments as part of the 2027/28 budget setting process. The committee also reviewed the Overview and Scrutiny Work Plan and the council's Forward Plan of Key Decisions.

Updates to the Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2027/28 - 2029/30

The committee received an update on the Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS), which forecasts a budget gap of £10.7 million in 2027/28, reducing to £8.2 million in 2028/29 and increasing to £9.8 million in 2029/30. These figures are based on current assumptions and are subject to change. The MTFS is a three-year financial plan that outlines the council's commitments and available resources to deliver its mission and priorities.

Officers from Corporate Resources, including Debbie Hogg, Executive Director of Corporate Resources, and Faye Tyas, Service Director of Finance and Technology, presented the strategy. They explained that the MTFS quantifies the cost of service delivery and highlights the challenges of managing rising demand and increasing service costs within available resources. The strategy appears on the Strategic Risk Register due to the fundamental importance of a balanced financial position for delivering services and achieving strategic priorities.

A significant portion of the discussion focused on the council tax increase. Councillor Maria Hollingworth questioned the assumption of an annual 4.99% council tax increase, including a 2% adult social care precept. Officers explained this is a working assumption to model the budget gap, and a 1% decrease in council tax would increase the gap by £1.6 million. The decision on the actual council tax increase remains with elected members.

Budget pressures in Adult Social Care were a key concern, with costs increasing due to higher demand for residential care, supported living, and homecare packages. Councillor Hollingworth asked about mitigation actions being developed. Officers stated that the figures reflect current demand and cost levels, and mitigation strategies will be developed as part of the budget process. The potential impact of a national adult social care fair pay agreement, which could add around £3 million in extra costs if not fully funded by the government, was also discussed.

Children's Social Care and SEND pressures were forecast at £2.3 million in 2027/28, driven by increased demand. Actions being taken include strengthening early help, prevention, increasing the number of foster carers, and keeping children local. School transport was identified as a £1.9 million pressure, primarily due to increased demand linked to SEND sufficiency assumptions.

The committee also discussed the council's overall service delivery model, with Councillor Hollingworth questioning if a fundamental review was needed rather than relying on annual savings exercises. Officers acknowledged the significant challenge and the need for difficult decisions, potentially impacting service delivery and head count. They highlighted that the current system was not designed for today's demographic and social care challenges, and that government funding was largely for universal services.

Regarding cost drivers, Adult Social Care, Children's Social Care, and School Transport were identified as the most significant. The sustainability of the council's operating model to 2030 was questioned, with officers stating that the system has not been sustainable for some time and requires government-level review and rebalancing of funding.

Efficiency within the council is measured through a blend of economy, efficiency, and effectiveness, with benchmarking and service standards being used for comparison. The committee also discussed the potential for electronic translation and AI to reduce translation costs in children's services.

Concerns were raised about outstanding parking and penalty charge notices, with a request made for figures on how much is owed and how the council identifies weaknesses in debt collection. Officers confirmed that while council tax and business rates debt is itemised, parking charges and penalty charge notices fall under sundry debt and can be provided by department but not by specific service type.

The structure of the council's officer tiers was discussed, with reference to a flat structure in private business that led to quicker work. The council's pay policy statement, which is published annually, details staffing numbers at each level and the span of control.

The committee noted the work plan for the Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee, including future discussions on quarterly performance reports, the corporate plan, and the budget.

Decisions Made:

  • The committee noted and commented on the latest MTFS position, including the projected budget gaps for 2027/28 to 2029/30, as part of the 2027/28 budget setting process.
  • The committee agreed that they had reviewed the information provided.
  • The committee considered the Overview and Scrutiny Work Plan 2026/27 and the council's Forward Plan of Key Decisions.

Decisions Still To Come:

  • The final budget will be considered by Full Council in February 2027.
  • Further details on the impact of the Doncaster Sheffield Airport takeover on the council's budget will be provided.
  • Clarification on parking notices and potential revenue loss from free parking will be sought from the Car Parking Service.
  • Figures on outstanding parking charges and unpaid penalty charge notices will be provided by the Service Director of Finance & Technology.
  • Further discussions on the MTFS and budget proposals will continue throughout the budget-setting process.

Attendees

Profile image for Councillor Karl Hughes
Councillor Karl Hughes Reform UK Stainforth and Barnby Dun
Profile image for Councillor Steve Cox
Councillor Steve Cox Conservative Group Leader Conservative Finningley
Profile image for Councillor Rebecca Booth
Councillor Rebecca Booth Reform UK Bentley
Profile image for Councillor Ken Guest
Councillor Ken Guest Labour Rossington and Bawtry
Profile image for Councillor Maria Hollingworth
Councillor Maria Hollingworth Reform UK Adwick and Carcroft
Profile image for Councillor Frank Jackson
Councillor Frank Jackson Reform UK Norton and Askern
Profile image for Councillor Jane Kidd
Councillor Jane Kidd Labour and Co-operative Party Wheatley Hills and Intake
Profile image for Councillor John Reed
Councillor John Reed Reform UK Mexborough
Antoinette Drinkhill
AHW_PA
Georgina Lightfoot
Marianne Courtney

Topics

social care precept Adult Social Care children's social care SEND pressures School Transport Service delivery model arrears management Pay Policy Statement Doncaster Sheffield Airport Executive Director of Corporate Resources Service Director of Finance and Technology Councillor budget setting process for 2027/28 Council's Forward Plan of Key Decisions Medium-Term Financial Strategy (MTFS) 2027/28 to 2029/30 Overview and Scrutiny Work Plan budget gap Council Tax increase

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 12th-Nov-2026 10.00 Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 12th-Nov-2026 10.00 Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee.pdf

Minutes

Printed minutes 12th-Nov-2026 10.00 Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee.pdf

Additional Documents

Minutes 17092026 Overview and Scrutiny Management Committee.pdf
Printed plan Forward Plan for the period 1st December 2026 to 31 March 2027 Cabinet 1.pdf
MTFS Update OSMC 12 Nov 2026 OSMC.pdf
MASTER WORK PLAN 202627 Agreed.pdf