Limited support for City of Edinburgh

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for City of Edinburgh Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Planning Local Review Body (Panel 1) - Wednesday, 22nd May, 2024 10.00 am

May 22, 2024 View on council website Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why was the 3 London Road pergola approved?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The meeting began with the appointment of Councillor Osler as the convener. The main topics discussed included a retrospective application for a short-term let at 102 Macleod Street, a roof extension at 128 Charterhall Road, and several other planning applications. The decisions made were based on the impact on residential amenity, conservation areas, and compliance with local development plans.

102 Macleod Street Short-Term Let

The application was for a retrospective change of use from residential to a short-term let for 250 nights per year. The property is a one-bedroom, third-floor flat in a predominantly residential area with some commercial uses nearby. The key issues discussed included the potential for increased noise and disturbance, the loss of residential accommodation, and the economic benefits of tourism. The application was refused due to concerns about the impact on residential amenity and the loss of housing.

128 Charterhall Road Roof Extension

The proposal was for a roof extension and a roof terrace on a mid-terrace property. The key issues were the visual impact on the conservation area and the potential for overlooking and noise. The committee was divided, but the application was ultimately refused due to concerns about the roof terrace's impact on the character of the area.

15 Coalbridge Millside Short-Term Let

This application was also for a retrospective change of use from residential to a short-term let. The property is a two-bedroom flat in a predominantly residential area. The key issues were similar to those discussed for 102 Macleod Street, including noise, disturbance, and the loss of residential accommodation. The application was refused.

9 Dewar Place Lane Short-Term Let

The application was for a change of use from residential to a short-term let for a maximum of 10 months per year. The property is a three-storey townhouse in a mixed-use area. The key issues included the impact on residential amenity and the loss of housing. The application was refused due to concerns about the loss of residential accommodation.

43 Jamaica Street South Lane Short-Term Let

This application was for a retrospective change of use from residential to a short-term let. The property is a one-bedroom flat in a predominantly residential area. The key issues were the impact on residential amenity and the loss of housing. The application was refused.

3 London Road Pergola and Stores

The application was for a retrospective pergola and two stores at a café. The key issues were the visual impact on the conservation area and the appropriateness of the materials used. The committee was divided, but the application was ultimately approved, overturning the officer's recommendation.

36 South Oswald Road Extension

The proposal was for a rear extension, garage conversion, and other alterations to a listed building. The key issue was the impact on mature trees on the site. The committee decided to continue the application to seek additional information on the construction method and its impact on the trees.

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorLezley Marion Cameron
Councillor Lezley Marion Cameron  Independent •  Ward 16 - Liberton / Gilmerton
Profile image for CouncillorNeil Gardiner
Councillor Neil Gardiner  Scottish National Party •  Ward 2 - Pentland Hills
Profile image for CouncillorTim Jones
Councillor Tim Jones  Scottish Conservatives •  Ward 17 - Portobello / Craigmillar
Profile image for CouncillorHal Osler
Councillor Hal Osler  Scottish Liberal Democrats •  Ward 5 - Inverleith
Profile image for CouncillorAlex Staniforth
Councillor Alex Staniforth  Scottish Green Party •  Ward 14 - Craigentinny / Duddingston

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 22nd-May-2024 10.00 Planning Local Review Body Panel 1

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 22nd-May-2024 10.00 Planning Local Review Body Panel 1

Additional Documents

6.2c - 128 Charterhall Road Edinburgh - Further Reps
8.1a - Edinburgh Design Guidance 2020
8.1a - Edinburgh Guidance for Householders
8.1a - Listed_Buildings_and_Conservation_Areas_Guidance_March_2018
8.1b - Coltbridge Wester Coates_CACA
7.1b - national-planning-framework-4 1
8.1a - business_guidance_April_2018
8.1a - Business_Guidance_April_2023
6.4a - 9 Dewar Place Lane Edinburgh - Decision Notice Report of Handling
4.1 - Minute - 24.04.24
6.1a - 102 Buccleuch Street Edinburgh - LRB Decision Notice Report of handling and Reps
5.1 - LRB Procedure
6.1b - 102 Buccleuch Street Edinburgh - LRB Form Notice of Review and Supporting Documents
6.2a - 128 Charterhall Road Edinburgh - Decision Notice Report of Handling Rep
6.2b - 128 Charterhall Road Edinburgh - LRB Notice of Review Form Supporting Documents
6.4b - 9 Dewar Place Lane Edinburgh - LRB Notice of Review Form Supporting Document
6.5a - 43 Jamaica Street South Lane Edinburgh - Decision Notice Report of Handling Consultation
6.5b - 43 Jamaica Street South Lane Edinburgh - LRB Notice of Review Form Supporting Documents
6.6a - 3 London Road Edinburgh - Decision Notice Report of Handling Reps
6.6b - 3 London Road Edinburgh - LRB Notice of Review Form Supporting Document
6.7a - 37 Milton Street Abbeyhill Edinburgh -Decision Notice Report of Handling and Reps
6.7b - 37 Milton Street Abbeyhill Edinburgh - LRB Form Notice of Review and Supporting Documents_R
6.8a - 36 South Oswald Road Edinburgh - Decision Notice Report of Handling Reps
6.8b - 36 South Oswald Road Edinburgh - LRB Notice of Review Form Supporting Documents
7.1a - Relevant Policies
6.3a - 15 Coltbridge Millside Edinburgh - Decision Notice Report of Handling Reps
6.3b - 15 Coltbridge Millside Edinburgh - LRB Notice of Review Form Supporting Document