Limited support for Aberdeenshire

We do not currently provide detailed weekly summaries for Aberdeenshire Council. Running the service is expensive, and we need to cover our costs.

You can still subscribe!

If you're a professional subscriber and need support for this council, get in touch with us at community@opencouncil.network and we can enable it for you.

If you're a resident, subscribe below and we'll start sending you updates when they're available. We're enabling councils rapidly across the UK in order of demand, so the more people who subscribe to your council, the sooner we'll be able to support it.

If you represent this council and would like to have it supported, please contact us at community@opencouncil.network.

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“What metrics will measure BSL plan success?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The council meeting focused on reviewing and approving various community-related proposals, including the implementation of a British Sign Language (BSL) plan, planning applications for property modifications, and a martial arts academy. The discussions were detailed, with inputs from council members, community representatives, and experts.

  1. British Sign Language Plan Approval:

    • About: The council reviewed the draft BSL plan for 2024-2030, aimed at enhancing accessibility and inclusion for BSL users.
    • Arguments: There was support for the plan's comprehensive approach, though some members sought clarification on metrics for success and broader community engagement strategies.
    • Implications: Approval of the plan commits the council to specific actions and resource allocations to improve services for the deaf community, with potential long-term benefits for inclusivity.
  2. Planning Application for Property Modifications:

    • About: A property owner sought retrospective approval for modifications and the installation of solar panels in a conservation area.
    • Arguments: While there was some concern about the visual impact on the conservation area, the modifications were seen as minimal and the solar panels beneficial for sustainability.
    • Implications: The decision allows the property modifications to stand, setting a precedent for future considerations of sustainability versus historical aesthetics in conservation areas.
  3. Martial Arts Academy Planning Approval:

    • About: A proposal to change the use of a business unit into a martial arts academy.
    • Arguments: Discussions centered on the suitability of the location and the impact on local traffic and parking.
    • Implications: Approval supports local business and community health initiatives but requires ongoing monitoring of traffic and parking impacts.

Interesting Event: During the meeting, there was notable emphasis on ensuring that all future council meetings and communications are more accessible, including potentially providing BSL interpretation, reflecting a growing awareness and responsiveness to inclusivity needs. The council meeting focused on discussing a proposed public procession by the Orange Order in Stonehaven, addressing community concerns, legal frameworks, and public safety. The committee heard from various stakeholders including legal officers, police representatives, community council members, and the organizers.

  1. Decision on Public Procession: The committee deliberated on whether to allow the Orange Order's procession. Arguments for the procession emphasized rights to peaceful assembly under human rights law, while opponents cited potential public disorder and community disruption. The police outlined plans to manage the event and mitigate risks. The decision's implications revolve around balancing civil liberties with community safety and local sentiment.

  2. Consideration of Community Feedback: Extensive community feedback was presented, showing significant opposition due to fears of sectarian violence and disruption. The committee had to consider this feedback seriously, weighing it against legal obligations to allow peaceful assemblies. The decision impacts community relations and the council's responsiveness to public concerns.

  3. Traffic and Safety Measures: Discussions on traffic management and safety measures were held, with the police detailing the operational plan to ensure public safety. The decision on this aspect was crucial for minimizing disruption and ensuring that the procession, if approved, would have a minimal negative impact on the local community.

Surprisingly, the meeting revealed a high level of organized opposition, including a petition with thousands of signatures, indicating strong community mobilization against the procession. This level of engagement highlighted the deep divisions and strong feelings surrounding the event. The council meeting focused on a contentious debate regarding the approval of a public procession by the Orange Order. The discussion centered on balancing the right to assemble against potential public safety concerns and disruptions.

Decision on Public Procession: The council deliberated on whether to permit the Orange Order's march. Proponents argued for the group's right to assemble and express themselves, citing human rights laws. Opponents raised concerns about public safety, potential for disorder, and disruption to local businesses. The decision to permit the march was heavily debated, with legal advice suggesting that the procession could legally proceed under specific conditions aimed at managing public safety. The implications of this decision involve careful monitoring of the event to prevent any disturbances and uphold the conditions set forth.

Additional Information: The meeting was marked by intense discussions and legal consultations, reflecting the complexity of balancing civil liberties with community safety. The involvement of legal advisors highlighted the council's cautious approach to a potentially divisive issue. The decision underscored the council's commitment to upholding rights while considering community impact.

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorSarah Dickinson
Councillor Sarah Dickinson  Scottish Liberal Democrats •  Ward 18 - Stonehaven and Lower Deeside
Profile image for CouncillorGeorge Carr
Councillor George Carr  Scottish Conservative and Unionist •  Ward 19 - Mearns
Profile image for CouncillorWendy Agnew
Councillor Wendy Agnew  Scottish Conservative and Unionist •  Ward 18 - Stonehaven and Lower Deeside
Profile image for CouncillorDavid Aitchison
Councillor David Aitchison  Scottish National Party •  Ward 17 - North Kincardine
Profile image for CouncillorDawn Black
Councillor Dawn Black  Scottish National Party •  Ward 18 - Stonehaven and Lower Deeside
Profile image for CouncillorShirley Burnett
Councillor Shirley Burnett  Scottish Conservative and Unionist •  Ward 17 - North Kincardine
Profile image for CouncillorLaurie Carnie
Councillor Laurie Carnie  Reform UK •  Ward 19 - Mearns
Profile image for CouncillorAlison Evison
Councillor Alison Evison  Independent •  Ward 19 - Mearns
Profile image for CouncillorMel Sullivan
Councillor Mel Sullivan  Scottish Liberal Democrats •  Ward 17 - North Kincardine
Profile image for CouncillorAlan Turner
Councillor Alan Turner  Scottish Conservative and Unionist •  Ward 18 - Stonehaven and Lower Deeside
Profile image for CouncillorCatherine Victor
Councillor Catherine Victor  Scottish National Party •  Ward 17 - North Kincardine

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 05th-Mar-2024 09.30 Kincardine and Mearns Area Committee

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 05th-Mar-2024 09.30 Kincardine and Mearns Area Committee

Additional Documents

Appendix 1 Draft Aberdeenshire BSL Plan 2024-2030
IIA-001816 BSL Local Plan
Public Processions Report
KM 5 March 2024 Draft Aberdeenshire British Sign Language BSL Plan 2024-30
Minutes 13022024 Kincardine and Mearns Area Committee
APP-2022-1589 - PDF Report
APP-2022-1589 All reps
APP-2023-2106 - Rep
Printed minutes 05th-Mar-2024 09.30 Kincardine and Mearns Area Committee
APP-2023-2258 - PDF Report
APP-2023-2106 - PDF Report
Appendix 1 - Notice of Procession Application
Appendix 2- Representation
Appendix 3 - Written Submissions revised
Appendix 4 - Legal Test
Statement of Outstanding Business 05.03.2024
Appendix 5 - Procedure