Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Barnet Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Council - Tuesday 15th October, 2024 7.00 pm

October 15, 2024 at 7:00 pm Council View on council website Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why did councillors disagree about Winter Fuel Allowance means-testing?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Open Council Network is an independent organisation. We report on Barnet and are not the council. About us

The Council of Barnet Council convened on Tuesday 15 October 2024, addressing a range of significant issues including the administration's achievements, the impact of government decisions on pensioners, and the outcomes of Ofsted inspections for children's services. Key decisions included the approval of the Local Pension Board's annual report and amendments to the Council's constitution.

Administration Achievements and Government Policy on Pensioners

Councillor Sue Baker's motion celebrating the administration's achievements was carried with 36 votes in favour to 16 against. The motion highlighted numerous initiatives undertaken since May 2022, including improvements to CCTV systems, the return of community skips, regular street deep cleans, a £97 million programme to fix roads and pavements, and the delivery of new council homes. It also noted the Outstanding Ofsted inspection for children in care and the first Barnet Pride celebration. The motion contrasted these achievements with what it described as wasted years under the previous Conservative administration, criticising outsourcing to Capita and the reinstatement of the committee system.

Conversely, the opposition motion, proposed by Councillor Richard Cornelius, regretting the government's decision to punish Barnet's pensioners, was lost. The motion expressed concern that cutting Winter Fuel Payments and linking them to Pension Credits, combined with rising energy prices, would push pensioners into fuel poverty. It highlighted that Barnet has a significant number of pensioners, including many nonagenarians, who are particularly susceptible to cold. The motion also referenced the Labour Party's previous stance against such cuts and cited Age UK's concerns about the policy's impact.

Ofsted Inspections and Children's Services

Councillor Anne Hutton's motion welcoming the government's decision to end one- and two-word Ofsted judgements for schools was carried unanimously. The motion argued that such judgements oversimplified school performance and could cause undue panic or complacency. The council resolved to write to the Secretary of State for Education to express thanks for this change.

The council also noted the outcome of Ofsted's inspection of Children and Families services, which found the overall effectiveness to be Good. While The experiences and progress of children in care was rated Outstanding, areas for improvement were identified, including return home interviews, communication about living arrangements for care leavers, the timeliness of early help support, and management oversight of the local authority designated officer (LADO). An action plan for 2024-2025 was noted to address these areas.

Further discussion focused on Corporate Parenting Annual Reports, with the council resolving to ensure understanding of their statutory role and awareness of progress and challenges for children in care and care-experienced young adults. Reports on the Fostering Service, Independent Reviewing Service, and Barnet on Point (Children in Care Council) were noted.

Financial Management and Treasury Operations

The council noted the Treasury Management Outturn Report for 2023/24, which detailed significant changes in the council's treasury position. Borrowing increased substantially to £1,056.36 million by March 2024, while Treasury Cash reduced to approximately £45 million. This was attributed to increased capital expenditure, the use of cash-backed reserves for capital projects, and significant interest rate hikes. The report highlighted a liquidity management risk and the need for improved processes and strategic borrowing decisions. The council also noted the Treasury Strategic Priorities for 2024/25, focusing on data management, refinancing debt, and improving reporting.

Constitutional and Administrative Matters

Several administrative matters were agreed, including changes to committee memberships and nominations to outside bodies. The council approved the draft calendar of meetings for 2025/26. Amendments to the Council's Constitution were also approved, including changes to land and property transaction authorisations, committee procedure rules, and the terms of reference for the Local Pension Board.

Chief Officer Appointments

The council noted the appointment of Craig Miller as Executive Director Environment and Naisha Polaine as Executive Director Growth. Dr Janet Djomba was designated as the Director of Public Health.

Other Motions

Motions regarding residents' ability to park outside their own homes and celebrating Barnet's Assets of Community Value were carried. A motion concerning leaseholders was amended and carried, calling on the leader to write to the Secretary of State supporting leasehold reforms. The motion welcoming the new 310 bus route was also carried.

The meeting concluded with the noting of the Annual Report of the Local Pension Board for 2023-2024.

Delegated decisions linked to this meeting

Decision summaries below are AI-generated from the council’s published record. Check the council source or the full decision page before relying on them.

Attendees

Profile image for Ernest Ambe Esq
Ernest Ambe Esq Labour West Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Richard Barnes
Councillor Richard Barnes Labour Barnet Vale
Profile image for Councillor Alex Prager
Councillor Alex Prager Conservative Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Gill Sargeant
Councillor Gill Sargeant Labour Colindale South
Profile image for Councillor Simon Radford
Councillor Simon Radford Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability Labour East Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Andrea Bilbow OBE
Councillor Andrea Bilbow OBE Labour West Hendon
Profile image for Mark Shooter
Mark Shooter Reform UK Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Nagus Narenthira
Councillor Nagus Narenthira Cabinet Member for Equalities, Poverty Reduction and the Voluntary and Community Sector Labour Colindale South
Profile image for Linda Lusingu
Linda Lusingu Independent Friern Barnet
Profile image for Edith David
Edith David Deputy Mayor Labour East Barnet
Profile image for Ella Rose
Ella Rose Labour Whetstone
Profile image for Laithe Jajeh
Laithe Jajeh Independent Mill Hill
Profile image for Val Duschinsky
Val Duschinsky Conservative Mill Hill
Profile image for Councillor Andreas Ioannidis
Councillor Andreas Ioannidis Labour Colindale North
Profile image for Councillor Peter Zinkin
Councillor Peter Zinkin Leader of the Conservative Group Conservative Golders Green
Profile image for Councillor Michael Mire
Councillor Michael Mire Conservative Garden Suburb
Profile image for Councillor Humayune Khalick
Councillor Humayune Khalick Deputy Mayor Labour Colindale South
Profile image for Councillor Shuey Gordon
Councillor Shuey Gordon Conservative Edgware
Profile image for Councillor Sue Baker
Councillor Sue Baker Labour Barnet Vale
Councillor Eva Greenspan
Profile image for Councillor Alison Cornelius
Councillor Alison Cornelius Conservative Totteridge & Woodside
Profile image for Councillor Kamal Bahadur Gurung
Councillor Kamal Bahadur Gurung Labour Burnt Oak
Profile image for Nigel Young
Nigel Young Labour Childs Hill
Profile image for Claire Farrier
Claire Farrier Labour East Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Danny Rich
Councillor Danny Rich Labour West Finchley
Profile image for Arjun Mittra
Arjun Mittra Labour East Finchley
Profile image for Paul Edwards
Paul Edwards Labour High Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Alison Moore
Councillor Alison Moore Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Health Labour East Finchley
Councillor Ammar Naqvi
Profile image for Councillor Ross Houston
Councillor Ross Houston Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Homes and Regeneration Labour West Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Rishikesh Chakraborty
Councillor Rishikesh Chakraborty Labour West Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Zahra Beg
Councillor Zahra Beg The Mayor of Barnet Labour Underhill
Profile image for Councillor Barry Rawlings
Councillor Barry Rawlings Leader of the Council; Cabinet Member for Strategic Partnerships, Economy, and Effective Council Labour Friern Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Elliot Simberg
Councillor Elliot Simberg Conservative Mill Hill
Profile image for Councillor Joshua Conway
Councillor Joshua Conway  Conservative  Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Sara Conway
Councillor Sara Conway Cabinet Member for Community Safety, Community Cohesion, and Ending Violence Against Women and Girls Labour Burnt Oak
Profile image for Councillor Alan Schneiderman
Councillor Alan Schneiderman Cabinet Member for Environment and Climate Change Labour Cricklewood
Profile image for Tim Roberts
Tim Roberts Labour Underhill
Profile image for Councillor Kath McGuirk
Councillor Kath McGuirk Labour West Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Jennifer Grocock
Councillor Jennifer Grocock Conservative Finchley Church End
Profile image for Councillor David Longstaff
Councillor David Longstaff Conservative Barnet Vale
Profile image for Councillor Nick Mearing-Smith
Councillor Nick Mearing-Smith Conservative Edgware
Profile image for Councillor Caroline Stock
Councillor Caroline Stock Conservative Totteridge & Woodside
Profile image for Councillor Dean Cohen MBE
Councillor Dean Cohen MBE Conservative Golders Green
Profile image for Councillor Lucy Wakeley
Councillor Lucy Wakeley Conservative Edgware
Profile image for Councillor Richard Cornelius
Councillor Richard Cornelius Conservative Totteridge & Woodside
Profile image for Zakia Zubairi
Zakia Zubairi Labour Colindale North
Profile image for Tony Vourou
Tony Vourou Labour Brunswick Park
Profile image for Councillor Anne Clarke
Councillor Anne Clarke Cabinet Member for Culture, Leisure, Arts, and Sport Labour Cricklewood
Profile image for Councillor Pauline Coakley Webb
Councillor Pauline Coakley Webb Cabinet Member for Family Friendly Barnet Labour Friern Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Philip Cohen
Councillor Philip Cohen Labour East Barnet
Profile image for Geof Cooke
Geof Cooke Labour Woodhouse
Profile image for Rohit Grover
Rohit Grover Conservative Garden Suburb
Profile image for Councillor Lachhya Bahadur Gurung
Councillor Lachhya Bahadur Gurung Conservative Edgwarebury
Profile image for Councillor Anne Hutton
Councillor Anne Hutton Labour Woodhouse
Profile image for Giulia Innocenti
Giulia Innocenti Labour Childs Hill
Profile image for Paul Lemon
Paul Lemon Labour Brunswick Park
Profile image for Giulia Monasterio
Giulia Monasterio Labour Brunswick Park
Profile image for Matthew Perlberg
Matthew Perlberg Labour Childs Hill
Councillor Daniel Thomas BA
Councillor Liron Woodcock-Velleman
Profile image for Sarah Wardle
Sarah Wardle Conservative Edgwarebury
Profile image for Councillor Emma Whysall
Councillor Emma Whysall (Labour and Co-operative Party) Labour High Barnet
Anisa Darr
Jessica Farmer
Chris Munday
Cath Shaw
Dawn Wakeling
Alana Baddoo
Corinna Demetriou

Topics

Liquidity management risk Local Pension Board's Annual Report Council's Constitution Capita Winter Fuel Payments Pension Credit Age UK Treasury Management Outturn Report for 2023/24 Affordable housing offer fuel poverty Children in Care (CiC) Treasury management Ofsted judgements for schools Treasury Strategic Priorities for 2024/25 Ofsted's inspection of Children and Families services Corporate Parenting Annual Reports leasehold reforms Care Leavers (CL) Early help support Assets of Community Value

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 15th-Oct-2024 19.00 Council.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 15th-Oct-2024 19.00 Council.pdf

Minutes

Printed minutes 15th-Oct-2024 19.00 Council.pdf

Additional Documents

Annex 1 Cabinet Report - CPAP Annual Reports.pdf
Council 15 October 2024 Report of the Monitoring Officer - Constitution Review.pdf
Appendix 1. Ofsted Inspection Letter 2024.pdf
Appendix B - Local Pension Board Terms of Reference.pdf
Supplementary paper - 16.2 Report of the Executive Director of Resources S151 Officer - Fees Ch.pdf
Administration motion in the name of Cllr Baker - Celebrating the administrations achievements.pdf
Administration motion in the name of Cllr Hutton- Ofsted inspections.pdf
Council 15 October 2024 Noting Chief Officer Appointments.pdf
Opposition Motion in the name of Cllr D Cohen- Residents Should be able to park outside their own ho.pdf
Administration motion in the name of Cllr Whysall - Celebrating Barnets Assets of Community Value.pdf
Opposition Motion in the name of Cllr R Cornelius -Lets help Barnets Leaseholders.pdf
Council Cover Report - Ofsted - 15 October 2024.pdf
Appendix 2. Ofsted Action Plan 2024-2025.pdf
Council report - 15 October 2024.pdf
Appendix A - Corporate Parenting Annual Report 2023 2024 final.pdf
Appendix B - Fostering annual report 2023 - 2024.pdf
Appendix C - Annual Independent Reviewing Service Report 2023 - 24.pdf
Council - Annual Report of LPB 2023-24 - Cover Report.pdf
Appendix A - Foreward from Chair Local Pensions Board.pdf
Council Cover Report - TMO - 15 October 2024.pdf
Treasury Outturn 2023-2024 Report.pdf
Appendix Ai - Part 4B1 - Land and Property Transactions Authorisation and Delegated Powers - Tables .pdf
Appendix Aii - Part 4B1 - Land and Property Transactions Authorisation and Delegated Powers - Tables.pdf
Appendix Bi - Part 3C - Committee Procedure Rules Tracked.pdf
Appendix Bii - Part 3C - Committee Procedure Rules Clean.pdf
Appendix Ci - Part 2B and 2C - Terms of Reference of Committees Tracked.pdf
Appendix Cii - Part 2B and 2C - Terms of Reference of Committees Clean.pdf
HoG report.pdf
Appendix A - Changes to Committee Appointments.pdf
Appendix B - Outside Bodies.pdf
Appendix C -Committee Date Changes.pdf
Appendix D- FINAL Draft Calendar 2025.26.pdf
Supplementary item 12- Member Questions to the Executive Chairs of Committees 15th-Oct-2024 19.00.pdf
Amendments to Motions 15th-Oct-2024 19.00 Council.pdf
Council Questions final.pdf
Administration amendment to Opposition Motion 14.6 -Lets help Barnets Leaseholders publishing.pdf
Printed minutes 09072024 1900 Council.pdf
Opposition motion in the name of Cllr R Cornelius - This Council Regrets the Governments Decision t.pdf
Administration motion in the name of Cllr Young - Welcoming the 310 bus route.pdf
Cabinet Report Children and families Ofsted inspection ILACS 290824.pdf
Appendix D - BOP Annual Report April 23 - March 24 LS.pdf
Annex 1 Local Pension Board Annual Report LPB 15 July 24 docx.pdf
Appendix C - Local Pensions Board Work Programme July 24 to June 25.pdf
App A - TM Outturn Report - 23-24 - Final.pdf
App B - PRIOR YEAR - Outturn Q1 and Mid-year Treasury Management Strategy and Performance update 20.pdf
Fees and Charges report 25.26 Council 15th Oct Publication.pdf
Appendix A Non-Exec FCs Council 15.10.24.pdf