Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Cornwall Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

The Monitoring Officer has decided that this meeting will not be livestreamed due to the pre-election period of heightened sensitivity. The recording will be made available after the elections, Cornwall Council - Tuesday, 15th April, 2025 10.30 am

April 15, 2025 View on council website

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why weren't Gaza investment questions answered live?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Cornwall Council met to discuss health and wellbeing board alignment, and the operation of special urgency provisions. Councillors also addressed questions from the public regarding 20mph zones, transport pricing in Truro, appointments, and investments related to the conflict in Gaza. The council approved recommendations regarding the Health and Wellbeing Board and Integrated Care Partnership alignment, and noted the report on special urgency and call-in provisions.

Health and Wellbeing Board and Integrated Care Partnership Alignment

The council approved recommendations to replace Article 18 of the constitution, concerning the Joint Health and Wellbeing Board Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly, with new terms of reference effective from 20 May 2025. The Monitoring Officer was delegated authority to make necessary changes to the 'Responsibility for Functions' section of the constitution to enact this decision.

The council also delegated authority to the Strategic Director for Care and Wellbeing to make minor amendments to Article 18, including accommodating changes from the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated Care Board and the Council of the Isles of Scilly resulting from their own governance approval processes.

The aim is to ensure that each fulfils its statutory duties and roles, but they are complimentary and interconnected. The 5-year joint forward plan (produced by the ICB and NHS trusts and foundation trusts) should be used as a mechanism for delivering the Integrated Care Strategy, along with the Councils’ own plans across Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly.

Operation of Special Urgency and Call-in Provisions

The council noted the number of occasions that urgency and call-in provisions have been used in the municipal year 2024-2025 to date. They took assurance from the Constitution and Governance Committee’s assessment that no changes to the provisions are currently required.

Questions from the Public

The council addressed nine questions from the public, and agreed to send written replies to the questioners. The questions covered a range of topics:

  • 20mph Zones: Mr Lightfoot from Carnon Downs asked for the publication of consultation results justifying 20mph zones.
  • Truro Transport Pricing: Mr Egerton from Grampound questioned the logic behind increasing Truro park and ride prices while freezing city centre car park prices.
  • Appointment of Head of Air and Space: Mr Smith from St Mabyn asked if the Corserv shareholder agreed with North Cornwall MP Ben Maguire's concerns about transparency, integrity, and public trust regarding the appointment of Councillor Louis Gardner to Head of Air and Space.
  • Chairman of Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Economic Forum: Mr Osmond from Constantine, Ms Cuff from Delabole, and Ms Fleet from Bodmin asked if the council would demand that Lord Hutton resign his directorship of the Israel-owned military supplier Pearson Engineering, as a precondition for his continued leadership of the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Economic Forum, given the ongoing conflict in Gaza and the ICC’s recognition of its criminality.
  • Council Investments: Mrs and Mr Bennett from Truro questioned how the council morally justifies its investments in arms to Israel, given the ongoing conflict in Gaza.
  • Council Pension Fund Investments: Mr Hilley from Truro asked if the council would ensure that all councillors involved in making investment decisions avoid providing financial assistance to any state guilty of serially contravening international law.
  • Pension Fund Investments: Mr Baines from Truro asked if the council would review its policies on pensions investment and official representation to ensure it is not complicit in genocide, given local MPs' grave concern at actions by the Israeli Government and defence forces.
  • Council Tax: Mr Newham from Redruth asked if councillors agreed that it is ok to use public funds in this way, given that the council is currently investing some council tax in companies enabling illegal acts of genocide in Gaza.
  • Nolan Principles: Mr Elliot from Truro asked if the Leader of Cornwall Council believes that the Nolan Principles1 must apply to all Members of Cornwall Council Cabinet at all times.

Questions from Members to Members of the Cabinet

Councillor Michael Bunney asked the Leader of the Council to provide a written response on whether all investments are ethical and do not support military action which harm children.

Councillor John Fitter asked Councillor Connor Donnithorne, Portfolio Holder for Transport, to provide a written response in respect of the position for Members being liable for costs when responding to a consultation under the Highways Act 1980.2


  1. The Nolan Principles, also known as the seven principles of public life, are a set of ethical guidelines for those working in the public sector. They include selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership. 

  2. The Highways Act 1980 is an Act of Parliament in the United Kingdom that consolidates and amends the law relating to highways, streets and bridges. 

Attendees

Profile image for %= (person.title + Martyn Alvey" class="person-image" >
Martyn Alvey Deputy Group Leader - Conservative Group • Conservative
Profile image for %= (person.title + Steve Arthur" class="person-image" >
Steve Arthur  Deputy Group Leader - Non Aligned •  Non-aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Stephen Barnes" class="person-image" >
Stephen Barnes  Deputy Group Leader - Labour Party •  Labour
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Bastin" class="person-image" >
John Bastin  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Michael Bunney" class="person-image" >
Michael Bunney  Mebyon Kernow/Green Group
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jim Candy" class="person-image" >
Jim Candy Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Channon" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Nicky Chopak" class="person-image" >
Nicky Chopak Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Brian Clemens" class="person-image" >
Brian Clemens Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Dick Cole" class="person-image" >
Dick Cole Group Leader - Mebyon Kernow Group • Mebyon Kernow
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Conway" class="person-image" >
John Conway  Group Leader - Non Aligned •  Non-aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Dave Crabtree" class="person-image" >
Dave Crabtree  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Nick Craker" class="person-image" >
Nick Craker  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jennifer Cruse" class="person-image" >
Jennifer Cruse  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Sharon Daw" class="person-image" >
Sharon Daw  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Philip Desmonde" class="person-image" >
Philip Desmonde  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Connor Donnithorne" class="person-image" >
Connor Donnithorne Group Leader - Conservative Group • Conservative
Profile image for %= (person.title + Anne Double" class="person-image" >
Anne Double  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Tim Dwelly" class="person-image" >
Tim Dwelly Portfolio Holder for Economic Regeneration and Investment • Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Barbara Ellenbroek" class="person-image" >
Barbara Ellenbroek  Portfolio Holder for Children and Families •  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kate Ewert" class="person-image" >
Kate Ewert Group Leader - Labour and Co-operative Group • Labour & Cooperative Party
Profile image for %= (person.title + Dominic Fairman" class="person-image" >
Dominic Fairman  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Fitter" class="person-image" >
John Fitter  Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Guy Foreman" class="person-image" >
Guy Foreman  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Hilary Frank" class="person-image" >
Hilary Frank Portfolio Holder for Children, Families and Schools • Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Leigh Frost" class="person-image" >
Leigh Frost Leader of the Council & Group Leader - Liberal Democrat Group • Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Louis Gardner" class="person-image" >
Louis Gardner  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Andrew George" class="person-image" >
Andrew George  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Julian German" class="person-image" >
Julian German Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Pauline Giles" class="person-image" >
Pauline Giles Independent Non Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Karen Glasson" class="person-image" >
Karen Glasson Conservative
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Guest" class="person-image" >
Peter Guest  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + David Harris" class="person-image" >
David Harris  Deputy Leader of the Council and Portfolio for Resources and Deputy Group Leader - Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned Group •  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Adrian Harvey" class="person-image" >
Adrian Harvey  Non-aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Loveday Jenkin" class="person-image" >
Loveday Jenkin Mebyon Kernow
Profile image for %= (person.title + Alan Jewell" class="person-image" >
Alan Jewell  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Barry Jordan" class="person-image" >
Barry Jordan  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Keeling MBE" class="person-image" >
John Keeling MBE  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Dorothy Kirk" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter La Broy" class="person-image" >
Peter La Broy Portfolio Holder for Housing • Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Sheila Lennox-Boyd" class="person-image" >
Sheila Lennox-Boyd  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Andrew Long" class="person-image" >
Andrew Long Deputy Group Leader - Mebyon Kernow Group • Mebyon Kernow
Profile image for %= (person.title + Matthew Luke" class="person-image" >
Matthew Luke  Mebyon Kernow/Green Group
Profile image for %= (person.title + Laurie Magowan" class="person-image" >
Laurie Magowan Deputy Group Leader - Labour and Co-operative Group • Labour & Cooperative Party
Profile image for %= (person.title + Thalia Marrington" class="person-image" >
Thalia Marrington Portfolio Holder for Community Safety and Public Health and Deputy Group Leader - Liberal Democrat Group • Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Colin Martin" class="person-image" >
Colin Martin  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Martin" class="person-image" >
John Martin Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jim McKenna" class="person-image" >
Jim McKenna Portfolio Holder for Adult Social Care and Health Partnerships • Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Mike McLening" class="person-image" >
Mike McLening  Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Andrew Mitchell" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Pete Mitchell" class="person-image" >
Pete Mitchell Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Oliver Monk" class="person-image" >
Oliver Monk  Portfolio Holder for Planning and Housing •  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Robin Moorcroft" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Morgan" class="person-image" >
John Morgan  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Carol Mould" class="person-image" >
Carol Mould  Portfolio Holder for Neighbourhoods •  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + James Mustoe" class="person-image" >
James Mustoe Conservative
Profile image for %= (person.title + Rob Nolan" class="person-image" >
Rob Nolan Chairman of the Council • Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Adrian Parsons" class="person-image" >
Adrian Parsons Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jane Pascoe" class="person-image" >
Jane Pascoe Conservative
Profile image for %= (person.title + Lionel Pascoe" class="person-image" >
Lionel Pascoe  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Adam Paynter" class="person-image" >
Adam Paynter Deputy Leader and Portfolio Holder for Resources and Group Leader - Independent Group • Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Richard Williams-Pears" class="person-image" >
Richard Williams-Pears  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Perry" class="person-image" >
Peter Perry  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Loic Rich" class="person-image" >
Loic Rich Portfolio Holder for Environment and Climate Change and Deputy Group Leader - Independent Group • Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Pat Rogerson" class="person-image" >
Pat Rogerson  Liberal Democrat
Profile image for %= (person.title + Alan Rowe" class="person-image" >
Alan Rowe Labour & Cooperative Party
Profile image for %= (person.title + Jordan Rowse" class="person-image" >
Jordan Rowse Conservative
Profile image for %= (person.title + Stephen Rushworth" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + David Saunby" class="person-image" >
David Saunby Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Phil Seeva" class="person-image" >
Phil Seeva  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Anthony Soady" class="person-image" >
Anthony Soady  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Linda Taylor" class="person-image" >
Linda Taylor  Leader of the Council and Portfolio Holder for Economy and Group Leader - Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned Group •  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Thomas MBE" class="person-image" >
John Thomas MBE Vice-Chairman of the Council • Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Mike Thomas" class="person-image" >
Mike Thomas Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Shorne Tilbey" class="person-image" >
Shorne Tilbey  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + John Tivnan" class="person-image" >
John Tivnan  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Armand Toms" class="person-image" >
Armand Toms  Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Kevin Towill" class="person-image" >
Profile image for %= (person.title + Dulcie Tudor" class="person-image" >
Dulcie Tudor Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Andy Virr" class="person-image" >
Andy Virr  Portfolio Holder for Adults Social Care and Health •  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Sally Anne Weedon" class="person-image" >
Sally Anne Weedon  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Christopher Wells" class="person-image" >
Christopher Wells  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Paul White" class="person-image" >
Paul White Independent
Profile image for %= (person.title + Tamsyn Widdon" class="person-image" >
Tamsyn Widdon  Mebyon Kernow/Green Group
Profile image for %= (person.title + Peter Williams" class="person-image" >
Peter Williams  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Paul Wills" class="person-image" >
Paul Wills  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned
Profile image for %= (person.title + Martin Worth" class="person-image" >
Martin Worth  Conservative & Independent Conservative Aligned

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 15th-Apr-2025 10.30 Cornwall Council
Supplementary Agenda Pack - Questions from the Public 15th-Apr-2025 10.30 Cornwall Council
Agenda frontsheet 15th-Apr-2025 10.30 Cornwall Council
Supplementary Agenda Pack - Questions from the Public 15th-Apr-2025 10.30 Cornwall Council

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 15th-Apr-2025 10.30 Cornwall Council
Public reports pack 15th-Apr-2025 10.30 Cornwall Council

Additional Documents

Alignment of the Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated
Questions from the Public
Alignment of the Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated
Alignment of the Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated
Operation of Provision Relating to Special Urgency and Call-in - Report
Operation of Provision Relating to Special Urgency and Call-in - Appendix 1
Operation of Provision Relating to Special Urgency and Call-in - Appendix 2
Questions from the Public
Questions from the Public
Alignment of the Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated
Alignment of the Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated
Alignment of the Cornwall Health and Wellbeing Board and the Cornwall and Isles of Scilly Integrated
Operation of Provision Relating to Special Urgency and Call-in - Report
Operation of Provision Relating to Special Urgency and Call-in - Appendix 1
Operation of Provision Relating to Special Urgency and Call-in - Appendix 2
Questions from the Public
Minutes of Previous Meeting
Minutes of Previous Meeting