Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Barnet Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Council - Tuesday 1st November, 2022 7.00 pm

November 1, 2022 at 7:00 pm Council View on council website Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“What new housing developments were discussed?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Open Council Network is an independent organisation. We report on Barnet and are not the council. About us

The Council of Barnet met on Tuesday 1 November 2022, with the meeting being held at Hendon Town Hall. The council discussed a range of topics, including the impact of the mini-budget on the cost of living, the Safer Community Strategy, and changes to the council's constitution. Decisions were made on the adoption of the Safer Community Strategy, amendments to the council's constitution, and the approval of proposed fees and charges for 2023/24.

Tributes to Former Councillor Laurie Williams

The meeting began with tributes to the late Councillor Laurie Williams, a former councillor for East Barnet. Councillors Philip Cohen, Caroline Stock, Marianne Haylett, Jennifer Grocock, Tim Roberts, and Alison Cornelius shared their memories and paid tribute to his dedication to the community. A minute's silence was observed in his memory.

Official Announcements

The Mayor, Councillor Alison Moore, made several official announcements:

  • Congratulations were extended to Councillor Dan Thomas and his wife Victoria on the birth of their son, Noah.
  • The Council had received the Defence Employer Recognition Silver Award and was aiming for Gold.
  • The success of Black History Month events across the borough was commended.
  • A reception had been held to mark the 50th anniversary of the Ugandan-Asian arrival in Barnet.
  • Remembrance Sunday was noted, with thanks extended to councillors representing the Mayoralty in laying wreaths.
  • Civic Awards nominations were open, closing on 31 December 2022.
  • Holocaust Memorial Day would be held on 29 January 2023 at Middlesex University.
  • Barnet had officially celebrated Diwali at Hendon Town Hall.

Questions to the Leader

The Council noted amendments to the written answers for questions 24 and 46. Question 24 was amended to read None - we're not increasing the charge, and Question 46 was amended to There won't be an increase. It was clarified that a proposed increase had been incorrectly included in a report to the Policy & Resources Committee on 29 September 2022.

Reports from Committees

Annual Report of the Audit Committee 2021/22 Councillor Arjun Mittra, Chair of the Audit Committee, moved the reception and adoption of the recommendations in the report. The Council resolved to note and approve the Annual Report of the Audit Committee for 2021/22.

Safer Community Strategy 2022-27 Councillor Sara Conway, Chair of the Communities, Leadership & Libraries Committee, moved the reception and adoption of the recommendations in the report. The Council resolved to note and approve the Barnet Safety Communities Strategy 2022-2027.

Constitution Review Councillor Barry Rawlings, Chair of the Constitution and General Purposes Committee, moved the reception and adoption of the recommendations in the report. Following a vote, the recommendations were agreed, with 36 votes in favour and 21 against. The Council resolved to note the report, approve the Constitution amendments, and authorise the Monitoring Officer to implement these revisions and publish a revised Constitution.

Fees and Charges 2022/23 & 2023/24 Council noted that an addendum report had been published on the Fees and Charges consultation findings and the Equalities Impact Assessment. Councillor Barry Rawlings moved the reception and adoption of the recommendations. Following a vote, the recommendations were agreed, with 36 votes in favour and 21 against. The Council resolved to approve the proposed fees and charges for 2023/24.

Report of the Head of Governance The Head of Governance introduced the report outlining various administrative matters. Council resolved to note and approve the appointments to Outside Bodies and Other Appointments as detailed in the appendices, and to approve changes to Committee memberships.

Motions for Debate

Impact of the mini-budget on the cost-of-living crisis Councillor Simon Radford moved an administration motion regarding the impact of the mini-budget. Councillor Dan Thomas moved an amendment, which was lost. Councillor Emma Whysall moved a further amendment, which was carried. The motion, as amended by Councillor Whysall, was then carried. The Council resolved to note the impact of the mini-budget, the subsequent government changes, and the strain placed on the local economy and residents. It was resolved to ask the Leader of the Council to write to the Prime Minister outlining these concerns and requesting further government support. Barnet's three Conservative MPs were also asked to write to the Government in support of these needs.

Council pledges to not raise parking charges until the cost-of-living crisis has been alleviated Councillor Dan Thomas moved an opposition motion to freeze parking charges. The motion was lost.

Standing up for responsible tax conduct Councillor Paul Lemon moved an administration motion on responsible tax conduct. The motion was carried. The Council resolved to request that the Policy & Resources Committee consider the 'Councils for Fair Tax Declaration' in the context of LB Barnet's developing procurement strategy.

Council will not raise the price of Garden Waste from £70 collections for the remainder of the administration to help with the cost-of-living crisis Council noted that an amendment by Councillor Alan Schneiderman had been withdrawn. The motion in the name of Councillor Dan Thomas was carried. The Council resolved to not raise the price of the garden waste collection service in Barnet for the remainder of the administration.

Becoming a Living Wage Employer: Accreditation Councillor Ernest Ambe moved an administration motion on becoming a Living Wage Employer. The motion was carried. The Council resolved to request that the Policy & Resources Committee consider the steps necessary for the Council to become a Living Wage Employer, including instructing officers to bring options to achieve accreditation to a future meeting.

A reduction is not a rebate - Labour must fulfil their manifesto pledge to rebate the Social Care Precept within the 2022/23 Financial Year Councillor David Longstaff moved an opposition motion. Councillor Barry Rawlings moved an amendment, which was carried. Councillor Longstaff then moved a further amendment, which was lost. The motion, as amended by Councillor Rawlings, was carried. The Council resolved to note that Barnet Labour promised to freeze council tax and refund residents this year's 1% council tax increase, and that the Labour administration has refunded residents the 1% council tax increase through a targeted £2m Resident Support Fund in 2022/23, and agreed to refund a further £2m through a universal 1% council tax refund in 2023/24.

Council commits to not joining neighbouring Labour-controlled Camden Council in restricting all council-operated roads to a 20mph speed limit Councillor Dan Thomas moved an opposition motion. Councillor Alan Schneiderman moved an amendment, which was carried. The motion, as amended by Councillor Schneiderman, was carried. The Council resolved to note that the LB Barnet Labour administration has a policy of agreeing 20mph zones on roads where a majority of residents support this, and to commit to listening to residents and only introducing 20mph zones where they are wanted.

Motions for Adjournment There were no motions for adjournment.

Motions that were not debated The following motions were noted as not having been debated:

  • 14.2 Opposition Motion in the name of Cllr Dan Thomas - Council pledges to not raise parking charges until the cost-of-living crisis has been alleviated. (This motion was debated and lost).
  • 14.4 Opposition Motion in the name of Cllr Dan Thomas - Council will not raise the price of Garden Waste from £70 collections for the remainder of the administration to help with the cost-of-living crisis. (This motion was debated and carried).

The meeting concluded at 9:26 pm.

Attendees

Profile image for Councillor Alison Moore
Councillor Alison Moore Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care and Health Labour East Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Nagus Narenthira
Councillor Nagus Narenthira Labour Colindale South
Profile image for Ernest Ambe Esq
Ernest Ambe Esq Labour West Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Richard Barnes
Councillor Richard Barnes Labour Barnet Vale
Profile image for Councillor Zahra Beg
Councillor Zahra Beg The Mayor of Barnet Labour Underhill
Profile image for Councillor Andrea Bilbow OBE
Councillor Andrea Bilbow OBE Labour West Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Anne Clarke
Councillor Anne Clarke Cabinet Member for Culture, Leisure, Arts, and Sport Labour Cricklewood
Profile image for Councillor Pauline Coakley Webb
Councillor Pauline Coakley Webb Cabinet Member for Family Friendly Barnet Labour Friern Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Dean Cohen BSc
Councillor Dean Cohen BSc Conservative Golders Green
Profile image for Councillor Philip Cohen
Councillor Philip Cohen Labour East Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Joshua Conway
Councillor Joshua Conway  Conservative  Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Sara Conway
Councillor Sara Conway Cabinet Member for Community Safety, Community Cohesion, and Ending Violence Against Women and Girls Labour Burnt Oak
Profile image for Geof Cooke
Geof Cooke Labour Woodhouse
Profile image for Councillor Alison Cornelius
Councillor Alison Cornelius Conservative Totteridge & Woodside
Profile image for Councillor Richard Cornelius
Councillor Richard Cornelius Conservative Totteridge & Woodside
Profile image for Edith David
Edith David Deputy Mayor Labour East Barnet
Profile image for Val Duschinsky
Val Duschinsky Conservative Mill Hill
Profile image for Paul Edwards
Paul Edwards Labour High Barnet
Profile image for Claire Farrier
Claire Farrier Labour East Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Shuey Gordon
Councillor Shuey Gordon Conservative Edgware
Profile image for Councillor Jennifer Grocock
Councillor Jennifer Grocock Conservative Finchley Church End
Profile image for Rohit Grover
Rohit Grover Conservative Garden Suburb
Profile image for Councillor Lachhya Bahadur Gurung
Councillor Lachhya Bahadur Gurung Conservative Edgwarebury
Profile image for Councillor Ross Houston
Councillor Ross Houston Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Homes and Regeneration; Deputy Leader, Cabinet Member for Homes and Regeneration Labour West Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Anne Hutton
Councillor Anne Hutton Labour Woodhouse
Profile image for Giulia Innocenti
Giulia Innocenti Labour Childs Hill
Profile image for Councillor Andreas Ioannidis
Councillor Andreas Ioannidis Labour Colindale North
Profile image for Laithe Jajeh
Laithe Jajeh Independent Mill Hill
Profile image for Councillor Humayune Khalick
Councillor Humayune Khalick Deputy Mayor Labour Colindale South
Profile image for Paul Lemon
Paul Lemon Labour Brunswick Park
Profile image for Councillor David Longstaff
Councillor David Longstaff Conservative Barnet Vale
Profile image for Linda Lusingu
Linda Lusingu Independent Friern Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Kath McGuirk
Councillor Kath McGuirk Labour West Finchley
Profile image for Councillor Nick Mearing-Smith
Councillor Nick Mearing-Smith Conservative Edgware
Profile image for Councillor Michael Mire
Councillor Michael Mire Conservative Garden Suburb
Profile image for Arjun Mittra
Arjun Mittra Labour East Finchley
Profile image for Giulia Monasterio
Giulia Monasterio Labour Brunswick Park
Profile image for Matthew Perlberg
Matthew Perlberg Labour Childs Hill
Profile image for Councillor Alex Prager
Councillor Alex Prager Conservative Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Simon Radford
Councillor Simon Radford Cabinet Member for Financial Sustainability Labour East Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Barry Rawlings
Councillor Barry Rawlings Leader of the Council; Cabinet Member for Strategic Partnerships, Economy, and Effective Council Labour Friern Barnet
Profile image for Councillor Danny Rich
Councillor Danny Rich The Mayor of Barnet Labour West Finchley
Profile image for Tim Roberts
Tim Roberts Labour Underhill
Profile image for Ella Rose
Ella Rose Labour Whetstone
Profile image for Councillor Gill Sargeant
Councillor Gill Sargeant Labour Colindale South
Profile image for Councillor Alan Schneiderman
Councillor Alan Schneiderman Cabinet Member for Environment & Climate Change Labour Cricklewood
Profile image for Mark Shooter
Mark Shooter Reform UK Hendon
Profile image for Councillor Elliot Simberg
Councillor Elliot Simberg Conservative Mill Hill
Profile image for Councillor Caroline Stock
Councillor Caroline Stock Conservative Totteridge & Woodside
Profile image for Councillor Liron Velleman
Councillor Liron Velleman  Labour  Whetstone
Profile image for Tony Vourou
Tony Vourou Labour Brunswick Park
Profile image for Councillor Lucy Wakeley
Councillor Lucy Wakeley Conservative Edgware
Profile image for Sarah Wardle
Sarah Wardle Conservative Edgwarebury
Profile image for Councillor Emma Whysall
Councillor Emma Whysall Labour High Barnet
Profile image for Nigel Young
Nigel Young Labour Childs Hill
Profile image for Zakia Zubairi
Zakia Zubairi Labour Colindale North

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf

Minutes

Printed minutes 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf

Additional Documents

Supplement - Safer Communities Strategy 2022-27 Print Version 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf
Supplement - Council Questions and Responses 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf
Amendments to Motions 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf
Addendum - Fees and Charges Consultation Findings 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf
Addendum to Item 12 Report of the Head of Governance 01st-Nov-2022 19.00 Council.pdf
Council Questions and Responses.pdf
01. Referral from Audit Committee Annual Report of the Audit Committee.pdf
Annex 1 - Annual Report of the Audit Committee 2021-22.pdf
Appendix 1- Annual Report of the Audit Committee 2021-22.pdf
01. Referral from CLLC Committee.pdf
Annex 1 CLLC Community Safety Strategy Public Consultation Update Final.pdf
Appendix 1 Barnet Comm Safety Strat. 2022-2027 V5.6 ppt.pdf
Appendix 1 - Barnet Community Safety Strategy Print Version.pdf
01. CGPC Report to Council - Cover Report.pdf
04. Appendix A - Article 7 - Committees Working Groups and Partnerships Tracked.pdf
05. Appendix B - Article 7 - Committees Working Groups and Partnerships Clean.pdf
Appendix B - EqIA Leisure Services.pdf
06. Appendix C - Financial Regualtions - Fees and Charges Tracked.pdf
Addendum Council Fees and Charges Consultation Findings.pdf
07. Appendix D - Financial Regualtions - Fees and Charges Clean.pdf
Fees and Charges 2022-23 and 2023-24.pdf
Appendix A Fees and Charges.pdf
Appendix A - EqIA All Fees and Charges Final.pdf
Appendix A- Outside Body Appointments November 2022.pdf
Report of Head of Governance.pdf
Appendix C- Changes to appointment of committees.pdf
Appendix B - Other Appointments.pdf
Cost of Living motion 1.11.2022.pdf
Opposition Amendment to Motion 14.1 - Cllr Thomas.pdf
Administration Amendment to Motion 14.1 - Cllr Whysall.pdf
Opposition Motion Parking Charges.pdf
Fair Tax Mark motion 1.11.2022.pdf
Opposition Motion Garden Waste.pdf
Adminstration Amendment to Motion 14.4 - Cllr Schneiderman.pdf
Living Wage accreditation motion 1.11.2022.pdf
Opposition Motion A reduction is not a rebate.pdf
Adminstration Amendment to Motion 14.6 - Cllr Rawlings.pdf
Opposition Motions Barnet roads speed limit.pdf
Administration Amendment to Motion 14.7 - Cllr Schneiderman.pdf
Minutes of Previous Meeting.pdf
03. Annex 1ii - Report to HWBB - 29 September 2022 - Future of the Health Wellbeing Board.pdf
02. Annex 1i - CGPC 6 October 2022 Constitution Review Report.pdf